Is it Cricket branded?
Cricket is the toughest nut to crack for SIM sharing across ATT partners without an unlock.
Example: Any AT&T style SIM will work in any AT&T or ATT mvno phone even without an unlock. GoPhone will work with ATT, GoPhone, ST, Cricket, Net10, what have you.
But Cricket does some hinky dink in their Firmware so that only a Cricket SIM will work in a Cricket branded phone. Weird and contrary to the rule that any ATT style SIM works in any ATT style phone...
If your phone was not unlocked by Cricket it is a no go.
If you need additional help or have more questions or details to share, please join the site so you can reply in this thread...