Welcome to the Android Central Forums Create Your Account or Ask a Question Answers in 5 minutes - no registration required!

View Poll Results: Where do you prefer your buttons?

Voters
11. You may not vote on this poll
  • On screen

    6 54.55%
  • Off screen (capacitive/physical)

    5 45.45%
Results 1 to 19 of 19
Like Tree3Likes
  • 1 Post By zorak950
  • 1 Post By A895
  • 1 Post By LeoRex
  1. Thread Author  Thread Author    #1  
    JR A's Avatar

    Posts
    41 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,564 Global Posts

    Default On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    I vote for off screen (capacitive) buttons.

    I have an LG G Pro (which is the most underrated flagship of Android phones IMHO), and was looking forward to the G3 and G Pro 2... but they have on screen buttons, which I do not prefer. Clunky, and they irritate me when I'm trying to watch a movie or get a full screen of something. Yes, I know KitKat addresses these issues, but it's still bothersome to the experience and I still prefer off screen buttons just like how the G Pro and S5/Note3 are...

    What say ye?
  2. #2  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    I've always been of the mind that if you're going to have a giant bottom bezel anyway, you might as well have hardware buttons. I have to say, though, Jellybean and Kit Kat have won me over to on-screen buttons. I thought they'd be annoying when I came to the Nexus 4 from the Nexus S, but I came to appreciate their dynamic qualities, and they always seemed to go away when it mattered. Now I have difficulty going without them.
  3. #3  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    I used to feel ambivalent between the two, but now prefer off screen buttons as I want full use of screen real estate at all times.
  4. #4  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    On screen is technically better. They are customizable and will never wear out and can be hidden. That being said I can understand physical Burtons being a note 3 owner. Have full screen all of the time does rock.
  5. #5  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Should the phone lock up, those onscreen buttons become pretty useless. I'll generally prefer capacitive.
  6. #6  
    xchange's Avatar
    Banned

    Posts
    415 Posts
    Global Posts
    479 Global Posts

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    I prefer onscreen. It helps me farm hbm wave G easier on Castle Clash and pillage your base on CoC
  7. #7  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Quote Originally Posted by z33dev33l View Post
    Should the phone lock up, those onscreen buttons become pretty useless. I'll generally prefer capacitive.
    Having owned devices with both, I can tell you they're equally useless when the phone locks up. If Android isn't responding, it doesn't matter where the command comes from. Android has become so much more stable over the past few years though that I don't really worry about such things anymore. I've only had to do a forced reset of my Nexus 4 once in the year and a half that I've owned it, whereas on the Nexus S battery pulls were a frequent necessity.
  8. #8  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Quote Originally Posted by z33dev33l View Post
    Should the phone lock up, those onscreen buttons become pretty useless. I'll generally prefer capacitive.
    ^^ 'Zactly!

    Sent from my N9005 using Tapatalk Pro
    I know nothing.
  9. #9  
    Ry
    Ry is offline
    Ry's Avatar

    Posts
    7,831 Posts
    Global Posts
    7,838 Global Posts

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    I have no preference.
    a.k.a. RyZR from HoFo
    Motorola Moto X (164.55.2.ghost_verizon.Verizon.en.US, KitKat 4.4.2)
    Motorola Moto G (173.44.20.falcon_cdma.Verizon.en.US, KitKat 4.4.2)
    Motorola DROID Bionic (98.72.22.XT865.Verizon.en.US, Jelly Bean 4.1.2)
    Google Nexus 7 2012 (KTU84P, KitKat 4.4.4)
    What other devices have I had? Here's my phone timeline.
    Support your favorite Android app and game developers. Pay for apps! And don't block ads!

    Community Rules & Guidelines - Mobile Nations Forums
  10. #10  
    JeffDenver's Avatar
    Banned

    Posts
    2,460 Posts
    Global Posts
    2,480 Global Posts
    ROM
    Perma-rooted and unlocked

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Quote Originally Posted by JR A View Post
    I vote for off screen (capacitive) buttons.

    I have an LG G Pro (which is the most underrated flagship of Android phones IMHO), and was looking forward to the G3 and G Pro 2... but they have on screen buttons, which I do not prefer. Clunky, and they irritate me when I'm trying to watch a movie or get a full screen of something. Yes, I know KitKat addresses these issues, but it's still bothersome to the experience and I still prefer off screen buttons just like how the G Pro and S5/Note3 are...

    What say ye?
    I use both on a regular basis. I prefer on-screen. Navigating is just much faster, and they change orientation with you...your controls are therefore persistent. And this makes navigation far more intuitive IMO.

    My HTC Rezound has a KitKat ROM...the first thing I did was disable those capacitive buttons and turn on on-screen buttons. It is so much better now.
  11. #11  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Quote Originally Posted by zorak950 View Post
    Having owned devices with both, I can tell you they're equally useless when the phone locks up. If Android isn't responding, it doesn't matter where the command comes from. Android has become so much more stable over the past few years though that I don't really worry about such things anymore. I've only had to do a forced reset of my Nexus 4 once in the year and a half that I've owned it, whereas on the Nexus S battery pulls were a frequent necessity.
    Yes, but what about the Wacom digitizer, or finger sensor thingy, going kaput. At least you can pretend to be doing something with the back, menu and home buttons. It's always better to have a bit of redundancy, ask a pilot.
    I know nothing.
  12. #12  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Quote Originally Posted by Madd54 View Post
    Yes, but what about the Wacom digitizer, or finger sensor thingy, going kaput. At least you can pretend to be doing something with the back, menu and home buttons. It's always better to have a bit of redundancy, ask a pilot.
    If the digitizer goes out, I struggle to imagine what you'd accomplish with just the capacitive buttons. Maybe if you had a trackball/pad, too...

    It's not as though you can't invent some situations in which it would be useful, but in general I've come to find them redundant. Redundancy is all well and good if the lives of 300 people at 30,000 feet are at stake, but for a phone, I think I prefer streamlined and simple. :P
  13. #13  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Quote Originally Posted by zorak950 View Post
    If the digitizer goes out, I struggle to imagine what you'd accomplish with just the capacitive buttons. Maybe if you had a trackball/pad, too...

    It's not as though you can't invent some situations in which it would be useful, but in general I've come to find them redundant. Redundancy is all well and good if the lives of 300 people at 30,000 feet are at stake, but for a phone, I think I prefer streamlined and simple. :P
    True. I've only had 2 Samsung's; before that Sony Ericssons with wheels and buttons and switches and buttons.
    I never had Android with on screen buttons, only tried some others'. I know Kitkat improved them and they disappear more quickly.
    I'll stay old school. Buttons and switches will make a comeback!
    I know nothing.
  14. #14  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Quote Originally Posted by Madd54 View Post
    I'll stay old school. Buttons and switches will make a comeback!
    Fight the power, man.
    Madd54 likes this.
  15. #15  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    On screen buttons. Power button and volume button on the right side. Motorola has spoiled me in regards to this.

    Posted via Android Central App
    Madd54 likes this.
  16. #16  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Starting to love the on screen better...
    Kinda getting use to it now..

    Posted from Google Nexus 5
    My History of Phones.
    2007 - 2011 iPhone 2G 3G 3GS 4G
    2012 - 2013 Samsung Galaxy S3 S4
    2014 - Google Nexus 5
  17. #17  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Quote Originally Posted by z33dev33l View Post
    Should the phone lock up, those onscreen buttons become pretty useless. I'll generally prefer capacitive.
    Just as useless as hardware buttons... in both cases, you're doing the Android equivilent of the three finger salute... in my Nexus 5's cases, it's hold down both up and down volume and the power button... after a timeout, it'll turn off. If your phone is torqued up, HW or SW... those nav buttons are toast.

    That being said, I've had phones that are on either camp and I MUCH prefer the softkeys. First, I've really come to like the look you get without the hardware buttons. The Nexus 5 and LG G2 just have a clean, high-tech look. I had an SIII prior to my Nexus 5, and the home button wasn't the most comfortable to use. I have large hands and had to turn my thumb (which I jacked up playing vollyball in HS) a bit to hit it right. I ended up using Pie controls on my SIII, ignoring the HW buttons completely.... once I went that route, that space was just wasted.

    Yes, softkeys do take a little away from the bottom of the screen.... but you can get that back easy enough with immersive modes, then get your keys back with something like using PIE. Or I can shrink the nav bar height, or add or remove buttons, lots of possibilities.
    A895 likes this.
  18. #18  
    icyrock1's Avatar

    Posts
    29 Posts
    Global Posts
    50 Global Posts

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    Captive/Physical, because when you search the internet in landscape mode, on screen buttons on my Nexus 5 go to the right hand side. I'm left handed. This is a HUGE inconvenience and annoyance. I would really like google to add a left-hand mode for the buttons.
  19. #19  

    Default Re: On screen vs Off Screen Buttons

    I've had both and prefer on screen buttons since they can be customized and on many phones adapt to screen orientation and various apps.

    Sent from my G2 running SOKP

Similar Threads

  1. Phone on or off when charging?
    By tonyr6 in forum Google Nexus 5
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 05-23-2014, 06:31 AM
  2. Screen capture issue
    By Luis Velasquez in forum Samsung Galaxy S5
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 05-22-2014, 03:40 AM
  3. PLEASE HELP I'm getting no sound on my avail 2 AT&T go-phone
    By JoshL1992 in forum Other ZTE Android Phones
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 05-22-2014, 01:18 AM
  4. Black screen
    By mechajoy0 in forum HTC One (M8)
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 05-22-2014, 12:20 AM
  5. GS4 Bluetooth stays paired, but won't keep "use phone audio" on
    By emkayca in forum Samsung Galaxy S4 Accessories
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 05-22-2014, 12:19 AM

Posting Permissions