Pixel Halo effect?

[dobo84]

Has anyone had any issues with a halo effect when shooting in sunlight?

there is a slight halo but others are reporting worse

 

[SteelGator]

That picture doesn't look bad to me, that said, halos are common in HDR. You may try turning it off for a shot like that and see how it does.

 

[dobo84]

That picture doesn't look bad to me, that said, halos are common in HDR. You may try turning it off for a shot like that and see how it does.

Was thinking that, I'm going to test tomorrow and see how it looks

 

[maizhaoiv]

I found there's kinda same issue from Danny Widget's Twitter: https://twitter.com/superscientific/status/789968924297297920.

 

[SteelGator]

I found there's kinda same issue from Danny Widget's Twitter: https://twitter.com/superscientific/status/789968924297297920.

Looking back at the original photo, now I see what you are talking about. Is wonder if that is more lens flare than HDR. When I think of HDR halo, it is a line around buildings where the meet the sky, and you see a bit of it around the house in that background. I would call the 'halo' I see in the OP pic lens flare. The same in Danny's pic, though I wonder if it is worse because of processing artifact due to HDR?

These links show good examples of both
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lens_flare
http://www.trentsizemore.com/2013/02/23/the-halo-effect-bad-hdr/

Based on what I see, the camera lens may be susceptible to lens flare, and shooting directly in to light (which I don't favor anyway) will require pics from a few angles to get a clean shot.

Any pro photographers out there to comment? I only know enough to be dangerous.

 

[dobo84]

tried this one no HDR to see and it's a bit more visible

 

[Richard Servello]

Has anyone had any issues with a halo effect when shooting in sunlight? //uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20161023/37cf770ed5ea8c5c3e1efa888f0e7f47.jpg there is a slight halo but others are reporting worse

That's called a lens flare or lens reflection. It happens when you shoot directly at bright objects. Light reflects inside the lenses and causes an artifact. All cameras will do this.

 

[dobo84]

I know what it is but this drastic, here is one shot with the iPad Pro

 

[dobo84]

Flare is there but the Halo is not, something has to be reflecting on the pixels lens. It's not a deal breaker but it's there

 

[Go0gle]

That's called lens flare, and even happens on $3000 camera lenses. When you point the lens directly into the sun like that, it's possible for the intense light to reflect inside the lens elements and you get the flare. The flare can appear in a variety of different ways depending on the lens construction. There is no lens on the planet that can eliminate this entirely. Try keeping the bright sun out of the frame and you should see it go away. Also, the difference between brightness of the *sun*(!) and that dark house is far, far, far, beyond what any HDR mode can deal with. Don't worry, your camera is working just fine.

 

[SteelGator]

//uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20161023/f8c0be7376cb2eb3259c03b620cc4c95.jpg tried this one no HDR to see and it's a bit more visible

As others mention, that is flare, not a halo.

 

[dobo84]

nah I'm not the only one and no never had a issue with other devices this extreme. My DSLR can mitigate the issues with a shield but as described in this video is what I went through
https://youtu.be/pfz8YmHmeJ4

 

[Way out west]

Is this happening with all models or mainly silver? I wonder if the reflection from the glass is affecting these photos

 

[dobo84]

Possibly white reflects glare a bit more

 

[Way out west]

Wonder if placing a matte skin over the glass will help the situation?

 

[dobo84]

Ordered a Google art case since the cut outs are smaller

 

[SteelGator]

Well you cannot argue, the lens is susceptible to flare. I pointed my at a light and get the flare as well. I fired up my N7 (bad choice of words, sorry), and saw some flare, but not nearly as bad as the Pixel. I am going to need to step up my use of the camera on the Pixel to make sure it is not going to be a problem for me.

 

[dobo84]

Possible they may silently fix the issue in later units. I'll see what a different case does.

 

[akin_t]

Possible they may silently fix the issue in later units. I'll see what a different case does.

You can't just fix lens flare without changing the entire assembly.

In very layman's terms, lens flare happens when stray light, i.e. light outside the lens field of view, makes its way to the sensor. In photography, you use lens hoods to block the stray light and thus eliminate the flare.

If it's any consolation, lens flare is really only a problem when shooting into bright sources of light.

 

[Richard Servello]

Possible they may silently fix the issue in later units. I'll see what a different case does.

Fix what? You are shooting INTO the sun! They can't change physics.