I had the hero before the Evo. I never had any problems with either. I use the Seido case and holster combo and never had a problem. Yesterday I look at my phone and I have about an inch scratch above the home key and a little nick on the right side. I have absolutely no idea how this happened. I did not drop the phone or even put it in the pocket with the keys. Was just bummed out. THought I would share because the screen can scratch. I baby my phones so very puzzled on how this could of happened.