I recognize Laura's name from the WP forums... hi there.
I just finished my 2 year commitment with my current phone, an HTC 8X with WP8. This was my first smart phone. I love the OS, but the fact that so many apps are missing from that ecosystem makes we want to look into Android.
Unlike Laura, I'm not "heavily invested" in WP. Although I like it, it was my first experience with smart phones and I don't mind trying something different. I'm on ATT&T and their free/cheap phones include:
LG G Vista, G2, G Flex2, G3, G3 Vigor
Samsung Galaxy Mega 2, Galaxy Note 4, Galaxy S5, Galaxy S5 Mini
Motorola Moto G, Moto X (2nd Gen)
From that "class" of phones, does anyone have any recommendations of what I should get? What are the pros and cons of the "best" of those, and are there any other brands I should look at?
I'm not a developer, so I don't need a fancy, high power device. I use it for calls and texts, social media (FB) and surfing the net, and simple offline games. Some things that seem neato include long battery life, ability to add storage (mini SD?), maybe some Euro capability (at least texting if not voice), good ergonomic design (boy my HTC 8X looks clean, but the buttons are TERRIBLE), maybe I'll think of something else....
I can do the compare things on the AT&T site, but they don't have the more subtle advantages/disadvantages that you figure out when you start using a device.