If they give you a hard time, remind them that it's illegal in all states, to sell a used phone - even if it's only been used for 2 minutes - as new, and that the FTC has put companies larger than Verizon out of business for it. (They find 2 more cases (and they'll have hundreds of people buying Note 4s from Verizon if they have to), prosecute under RICO, and ask for all gross income for the past 7 years as the fine. There's no company in the world that can survive that. [It's usually knocked down to 3 years, but that still puts almost any company out of business.]) Once a complaint like yours gets to corporate (and you can send the CEO a copy of the complaint you file with the FTC) an order something like a "give this man a brand new Note 4 that you checked personally" order goes to the district manager. And the FTC gets notified who got fired for causing a used phone to be put back into new stock. (I got investigated for that twice when I had my stores. The "contracts" were copies in each case, and it was just possible to make out where the "used" was whited out on the original. And it was plainly there on my copy. It's scary to lose a little store for a mistake. Losing your golden parachute with Verizon? [Which is more than my stores brought in - gross - in a year.] They'll fire everyone, raze the store and open one across town if they have to. The FTC takes it that seriously.)