Hello there...
I'm a future Android user, coming from an iPod Touch background and being fascinated with these nice little robot phones on display in my local malls.
It looks like my phone of choice will be the SIII, well at least it's the one with the most 'checks' in my book, but I have a problem with it. (Who doesn't, I guess.)
Problem is, I can't find anything on the web discussing that problem. It's like it doesn't exist, because people never complain about it. But I noticed the issue less than a few seconds after my first demo of the S3 in a shop. It screamed to me, 'look at that!', and then I proceeded to explain/demonstrate it to every single tech guy in these shops, and everytime they agreed there was something wrong, and no, they didn't know how to fix, they didn't even notice the problem was there before.
So, here it is.
Go to the Settings page, or a browser page, anything that's scrollable, preferably a long page so you can easily spot the difference.
Put your finger near the top of the screen. Move it below very quickly, and immediately move it up, then down, etc. It's important to do it quickly and not stop. Now look at how the screen is scrolling compared to your finger movements.
It's like it's trying to keep up but it can't. The screen is still scrolling to the bottom when you're already moving your finger up.
It's not a huge slowdown or anything, it just feels like the S3 is struggling to keep up.
Problem is, it's a quad-core phone. I've tested lousy cheap phones that had absolutely no problems with the same little exercise.
I was able to reproduce this on:
- Galaxy Note 1
- Galaxy S2
- Galaxy S3
The problem doesn't happen on:
- Galaxy Note 2
- any non-Samsung phones I've tested (mostly spent lots of time with Motorola Razr HD, Sony Xperia Arc S and Xperia S.)
So, it looks like the Note 2 'fixes' the issue. Or maybe it's the Jelly Bean update...? But I tested a friend's S3 phone last month, and it was running the JB update, and it had the same problem.
Now, even weirder -- the 'bump' scroll effect.
It's harder to reproduce, but it happens just the same on Note 1, S2 and S3, and similarly, doesn't appear on Note 2. So I think that it's directly related to the first issue.
Scroll through a long page, not too slowly, not too fast (don't send the page flying to the bottom.)
Now, immediately lift your finger. If you were at the 'right' speed, you can see the page scrolling this way: it will quickly accelerate compared to its current cruise speed, then quickly decelerate in the same fashion (creating a 'bump' feeling), then slowly decelerate normally until it stops.
On any other device, lifting the finger will result in the scrolling quickly slowing down to a halt. On my iPod Touch, the scrolling usually stops immediately as I lift my finger, which I really like.
That, I'm afraid, is something that makes me hard for me to read a web page as easily as I can do on my iPod. Which is a shame.
So... Can anyone reproduce this?
Is it a known issue of the Samsung line?
Does the fact that the Note 2 fix it, mean that a future software update will fix it for other phones as well? Or is it more of a hardware issue?
Can it at least be fixed by switching to a different ROM? I'd rather avoid that as much as possible, at least in the beginning, as it could cancel my (future) warranty.
This phone looks so great. I just can't accept the fact that browsing is ruined for me because of that. Just in case you're going to suggest one of these: I already tried modifying the Settings > Mouse & Trackpad > Pointer Speed, as well as disabling all animations in the Developer settings, both to no avail. It just isn't related to these things.
Hopefully someone can help, thanks in advance
I'm a future Android user, coming from an iPod Touch background and being fascinated with these nice little robot phones on display in my local malls.
It looks like my phone of choice will be the SIII, well at least it's the one with the most 'checks' in my book, but I have a problem with it. (Who doesn't, I guess.)
Problem is, I can't find anything on the web discussing that problem. It's like it doesn't exist, because people never complain about it. But I noticed the issue less than a few seconds after my first demo of the S3 in a shop. It screamed to me, 'look at that!', and then I proceeded to explain/demonstrate it to every single tech guy in these shops, and everytime they agreed there was something wrong, and no, they didn't know how to fix, they didn't even notice the problem was there before.
So, here it is.
Go to the Settings page, or a browser page, anything that's scrollable, preferably a long page so you can easily spot the difference.
Put your finger near the top of the screen. Move it below very quickly, and immediately move it up, then down, etc. It's important to do it quickly and not stop. Now look at how the screen is scrolling compared to your finger movements.
It's like it's trying to keep up but it can't. The screen is still scrolling to the bottom when you're already moving your finger up.
It's not a huge slowdown or anything, it just feels like the S3 is struggling to keep up.
Problem is, it's a quad-core phone. I've tested lousy cheap phones that had absolutely no problems with the same little exercise.
I was able to reproduce this on:
- Galaxy Note 1
- Galaxy S2
- Galaxy S3
The problem doesn't happen on:
- Galaxy Note 2
- any non-Samsung phones I've tested (mostly spent lots of time with Motorola Razr HD, Sony Xperia Arc S and Xperia S.)
So, it looks like the Note 2 'fixes' the issue. Or maybe it's the Jelly Bean update...? But I tested a friend's S3 phone last month, and it was running the JB update, and it had the same problem.
Now, even weirder -- the 'bump' scroll effect.
It's harder to reproduce, but it happens just the same on Note 1, S2 and S3, and similarly, doesn't appear on Note 2. So I think that it's directly related to the first issue.
Scroll through a long page, not too slowly, not too fast (don't send the page flying to the bottom.)
Now, immediately lift your finger. If you were at the 'right' speed, you can see the page scrolling this way: it will quickly accelerate compared to its current cruise speed, then quickly decelerate in the same fashion (creating a 'bump' feeling), then slowly decelerate normally until it stops.
On any other device, lifting the finger will result in the scrolling quickly slowing down to a halt. On my iPod Touch, the scrolling usually stops immediately as I lift my finger, which I really like.
That, I'm afraid, is something that makes me hard for me to read a web page as easily as I can do on my iPod. Which is a shame.
So... Can anyone reproduce this?
Is it a known issue of the Samsung line?
Does the fact that the Note 2 fix it, mean that a future software update will fix it for other phones as well? Or is it more of a hardware issue?
Can it at least be fixed by switching to a different ROM? I'd rather avoid that as much as possible, at least in the beginning, as it could cancel my (future) warranty.
This phone looks so great. I just can't accept the fact that browsing is ruined for me because of that. Just in case you're going to suggest one of these: I already tried modifying the Settings > Mouse & Trackpad > Pointer Speed, as well as disabling all animations in the Developer settings, both to no avail. It just isn't related to these things.
Hopefully someone can help, thanks in advance