07-22-2012 10:18 PM
30 12
tools
  1. chappo2000's Avatar
    There seems to be conflicting reports concerning the ability to turn on/off the camera shutter sound. Can someone with a GS3 in hand verify which is true:

    Can you, "Go to the camera app, settings & go down to shutter sound" to toggle the sound? Or is root access/modification required?

    Thanks.
    06-23-2012 11:00 AM
  2. KSmithInNY's Avatar
    Hopefully someone chimes in but I know for sure that has been removed from android source. If it's there, Samsung added it. If it's not there are apps in the market which claim to silence the shutter so it's worth a try.
    06-23-2012 11:09 AM
  3. Paul627g's Avatar
    KSmithInNY is correct it was removed from source.. Basically due to privacy issues/laws of people "secretly" snapping pictures when they shouldn't be... Camera sound is a big red flag to someone snapping a picture.

    Friend with the SGSIII said he hasn't found a way to disable it so safe to say its set to ON with no option to disable. So your gonna need to root and rename the camera shutter sound file ".ogg" to silence the sound or edit the build prop line if it exists or find an app.

    All which KSmithInNY has already said so I'm just repeating it.
    06-23-2012 11:19 AM
  4. kinster02's Avatar
    Just add a widget to mute the ringer and that will mute the camera or what ever way is quicker and convenient for you to mute.
    06-23-2012 05:32 PM
  5. Paul627g's Avatar
    From my experience even if you mute the ringer completely the Camera shutter will still be audible.
    markhallyo likes this.
    06-23-2012 05:34 PM
  6. KSmithInNY's Avatar
    From my experience even if you mute the ringer completely the Camera shutter will still be audible.
    Correct, thats exactly what the build property ensures.

    ro.camera.sound.forced=true
    06-23-2012 05:40 PM
  7. kjjb0204's Avatar
    Just to be clear, there are no laws requiring a shutter sound nor is there any law against muting the shutter sound.
    datgoldmember likes this.
    06-23-2012 06:03 PM
  8. eyecon82's Avatar
    id like to know as well....

    there are no laws that a camera has to make a sound...its pure bullcrap

    it pisses me off we can't also record phone calls when I could on my old Treo 700p
    06-23-2012 06:47 PM
  9. Paul627g's Avatar
    I agree guys, I'm not sure if there is any standing laws here in the states or overseas but obviously there is a reason for this since Google has removed the option to mute camera shutter within source as KSmithInNY has mentioned.

    The fix or work around is easy if your rooted... Not so easy if your un rooted....

    Personally I feel we should be able to mute the camera sound but I guess Google doesn't share that same feelings.

    Trust me first thing I will be doing when I get my SGSIII is fixing a few things in build.prop and also doing some hackery within other areas to my likings..
    06-23-2012 06:56 PM
  10. KSmithInNY's Avatar
    Just to be clear, there are no laws requiring a shutter sound nor is there any law against muting the shutter sound.
    Agreed, but Android source code is freely distributed globally (including japan and korea where shutter sound laws exist), so a global approach was needed in the source. Google removed the check box from within the camera, as that's common code, compiled the same for any country. Rather what they decided is to empower OEMs to either force it on, or allow it to be silenced when phone is silenced. The OEM is tasked with defining within their specific build, if the device should for sound or not.

    ro.camera.sound.forced=true <- This means sound always on
    ro.camera.sound.forced=false <-This means sound muted when device is muted

    NOTE: Some devices require editing of the local.prop instead which switches the values to 1 0

    It's easy to forget that android is worldwide, and while Google has no obligation to modify it forcing OEMs to do the heavy lifting to meet their laws, they opted for a simple solution that's is better than nothing. RIM and Apple have both locked shutter sound in, period. Google at least lets OEMs decide on their own.

    If i were samsung I'd be strictly maintaining a clean, structured source for all the devices so adding a toggle to the camera apk wouldnt be an option as now US devices would have to have a separately maintained variance. Rather defining properties for multiple devices requires no additional maintenance (again, because of how Google implemented it). Samsung should edit the local properties for the US devices to enable silencing shutter if phone is silenced.

    OK, thats the last time i want to discuss shutters I rarely even use cameras lol
    hiero likes this.
    06-23-2012 07:11 PM
  11. strabo231's Avatar
    Guys this is one you need to do a little research into, although it's not easy to find. I live in SC, and here in about half the counties in the state, being caught using a non shuttering camera in public is a 175 fine for the first offense. Be very careful about this one!

    Sent from my LG-VM670 using Android Central Forums
    06-23-2012 07:11 PM
  12. eyecon82's Avatar
    Guys this is one you need to do a little research into, although it's not easy to find. I live in SC, and here in about half the counties in the state, being caught using a non shuttering camera in public is a 175 fine for the first offense. Be very careful about this one!

    Sent from my LG-VM670 using Android Central Forums
    how could they ever catch you? even if they suspect you...you can't look at someone's phone without having already arrested them or having a warrant

    so even if they suspected you, they can't do crap..and by the time they get a warrant, just delete the photo and you'll be fine
    06-23-2012 07:13 PM
  13. strabo231's Avatar
    how could they ever catch you? even if they suspect you...you can't look at someone's phone without having already arrested them or having a warrant

    so even if they suspected you, they can't do crap..and by the time they get a warrant, just delete the photo and you'll be fine
    That's not completely true in every state anymore. Lots of states on the eat coast consider most laws around mobile phones primary offenses and not secondary anymore. Here if they suspect you ran off the road because you were texting or something, they are allowed to look now

    Sent from my LG-VM670 using Android Central Forums
    06-23-2012 07:18 PM
  14. mak916's Avatar
    06-24-2012 01:01 AM
  15. f1nzup's Avatar
    I wonder if SilentSnap will work? I have the app Camera ZOOM FX and it has the option to "Enable the Shutter Sound" by checking a box, or by unchecking the box the shutter sound will be disabled. On the S3 it doesn't matter whether the box is checked or not, you still get the shutter sound.
    07-13-2012 07:48 PM
  16. mak916's Avatar
    I can tell you as of right now there is nothing that will work to shut off the shutter sound. You have to root your phone or use a camera app that has the shutter sound option. And not all of the camera apps that have the option will work. I contacted the makers of silentsnap and they are aware of the problem with the GS3. It might work with some carriers, but it won't work with Sprint. I've spent a lot of time looking for something that will work good without root. So far no luck.

    Sent from my SPH-L710 using Android Central Forums
    07-13-2012 10:39 PM
  17. dtg755's Avatar
    so if the shutter sound is now forced in source does that mean roms like cm9 don't have the option?
    07-13-2012 10:44 PM
  18. tmags2's Avatar
    Download Silent mode widget by Jason Hull from play store. It's free and when you silence your phone it also silences your camera sutter without rooting.
    07-15-2012 12:10 PM
  19. eyecon82's Avatar
    Download Silent mode widget by Jason Hull from play store. It's free and when you silence your phone it also silences your camera sutter without rooting.
    it seems that apps works better on certain kinds of phones..does it work on sgsIII well?
    07-15-2012 01:30 PM
  20. MannyZ28's Avatar
    My buddy bought an AT&T GS3 at Best Buy at full price so he could use it on Straight Talk. I was messing with it to get the phone to work on their network and while I was on hold with a rep, I showed my buddy the burst shot mode in the camera. While looking through the camera settings, I found the option to turn the shutter sound off. It worked too! I looked on my Sprint version and it didn't have it.

    Weird.

    At the end of the night the update for AT&T GS3s came out so he installed it right away, so I don't know if that turned the shutter sound back on and eliminated the option in the settings menu or not, I will check next time I see him.
    07-15-2012 02:03 PM
  21. Skunkape60's Avatar
    I can tell you as of right now there is nothing that will work to shut off the shutter sound. You have to root your phone or use a camera app that has the shutter sound option. And not all of the camera apps that have the option will work. I contacted the makers of silentsnap and they are aware of the problem with the GS3. It might work with some carriers, but it won't work with Sprint. I've spent a lot of time looking for something that will work good without root. So far no luck.

    Sent from my SPH-L710 using Android Central Forums
    You are absolutely wrong. I posted a how to and it works perfecty but you need to be rooted.

    http://forums.androidcentral.com/sho....php?p=1967053

    ________________
    Just Flash It !!!
    07-15-2012 04:09 PM
  22. MannyZ28's Avatar
    I can now confirm that the AT&T model indeed has the ability to turn the shutter sound on and off. It's one of the rare times where an AT&T Model can do something software wise that the Sprint model can't. I wonder if the other carriers models have it or not.
    07-15-2012 08:42 PM
  23. mak916's Avatar
    You are absolutely wrong. I posted a how to and it works perfecty but you need to be rooted.

    http://forums.androidcentral.com/sho....php?p=1967053

    ________________
    Just Flash It !!!
    Read what I wrote again. I said you have to be rooted. "You have to root your phone or use a camera app that has the shutter sound option." "I've spent a lot of time looking for something that will work good without root."
    07-16-2012 11:04 PM
  24. mak916's Avatar
    Download Silent mode widget by Jason Hull from play store. It's free and when you silence your phone it also silences your camera sutter without rooting.
    Does not work for the GS3. Like I said before, looks like the only way to go is root it.
    07-16-2012 11:16 PM
  25. Skunkape60's Avatar
    Sorry. You are correct. You will not get rid of the sounds without root. Period. Not possible because they are in the system files. No app without root access can touch them. That's why so many apps require you to be rooted some apps need system access to work.

    _______________
    Just Flash it !!!
    07-17-2012 12:15 AM
30 12
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD