There's no way to compare two phone's battery life unless you had them side by side and did identical things with them.
From the OP's screenshots, it doesn't look like they used their phone much throughout the day. Facebook is at 4% and everything else is less than that. Screen on time alone doesn't suck battery life. If you are browsing the internet or playing games, your battery life will deplete rather quickly.
I agree.
I also see calls at the bottom of the lists. To me....testing battery life means doing almost everything on that phone you would normally do. I dont use GPS alot so thats probably the only thing I would leave off. But calls? Every time I see calls at the bottom in battery life posts....makes me scratch my head sometimes.
Also something to think about: I dont even do battery life tests anymore....cuz I live n work in a bad reception area. And every time I'm in a better reception area...I forgot to do one...lol.
Unless we all lived, worked, hung out in the same areas, did the exact same things on our phones...battery life threads are kinda pointless unless you give details, specifics of your battery use. What area you are in can effect battery life too. The last time I did do a battery life test...I did different things on my phone for 1/2 an hour to an hour. That included playing games, talking, web browsing, etc.
And didnt the OP say they were on an extended battery? So the thread title should be something else...since they arent on a stock battery. Thats like comparing performance of a phone with a ROM and overclocked to a stock phone.