Brandon,
If you have not made up your mind yet, here is what I plan to do.
I like hip holsters also, primarily because I know the phone will always be out of the way and I won't sit on it, or if it is in a front pocket, I won't lean against a counter or something and press hard against it. And the phone is just easier to get out of the holster for me. Some cases have a grip to them and make pulling in and out of pockets a little harder.
Because I have always used hip holsters, all my phones have been in great shape until the end of their life, and mostly this is without any other case at all.
I have had a couple holsters from Smartphone Experts, and have this one on order:
Smartphone Experts Side Pouch
I do plan to supplement this holster with a
Fly Grip and take advantage of their free case with the Fly Grip. I think this will all fit in the holster after the leather relaxes a little, will likely use the holster initially with just the phone, then will add the case, then attach the Fly Grip, as the leather expands over a couple weeks.
I am liking this set up because the case offered by Fly Grip easily comes off and on, and with the Fly Grip mounted on the case, for the 90% of the time I will be using the phone in my hand, or on a desk using the Fly Grip as a kick stand, the case/Fly Grip will remain attached. The few times when I will want the phone to lie flat on my desk for whatever reason, I can just easily remove the case and re-attach.
Anyway, that's my plan, hope it was helpful to you.