Elago G5 Slim fit case or Spigen Ultra Thin Air?

I am getting a S3 soon and want a thin case for my phone but one that has color. I found the Elago G5 slim and Spigen Ultra thin air and see mix reviews. Some love the G5 slim but others say it doesnt fit well and color rubs off. Seems like sorta same issues with Spigen UTA.

Anyone have these and how do you like/dislike them? Wife sorta wants a glossy case but i would rather not since they can be more slippery.

I have the Elago G5 and I like it alot. I worried about there no being enough lip to protect the phone face down but it is not bad.

I ended up ordering the ultra thin air. The look and feel is amazing. It is very thin. Now just got to wait a month 4/30 for my upgrade. Lol