- 05-16-2010, 08:57 PM #51
- 05-16-2010, 10:12 PM #52
- 05-16-2010, 11:17 PM #53
- 05-17-2010, 12:22 AM #54
I'm another launch day Pre owner who has pre-ordered an Evo at Best Buy. My progression over the last two years has been:
Treo 700p (2 years)
Treo 800w (4 months)
HTC Touch Pro (7 months)
Palm Pre (6/6 launch 11 months)
So far the Pre has been my favorite phone, but I'd hesitate to call it the best due to sluggish and inconsistent performance. I love nearly everything about webOS and I know I will miss my Touchstone but the hardware is in need of a major refresh and the Evo has what I'm looking for. Overclocking my Pre has kept it usable but even then it suffers from (what I consider at least ) slow performance at times. I've been lucky on the hardware front, still on my launch day Pre, but the screen has plenty of scratches and there's a crack underneath the surface (but it still works fine). I'm sure that over clocking it is reducing it's lifespan but it only has to last another couple of weeks at this point
If Palm were releasing hardware in the next month or so that was similar to the Evo (and with a slider!) I would probably stick with webOS but that's not happening, so the Evo it is. However I will be hanging on to my Pre and if the Evo (or more precisely Android / SenseUI) doesn't live up to my expectations in the first 30 days I can always switch back.
I don't think that will happen, though, based on my research of Android and Sense. While I like the functionality of webOS I have missed the home screen widgets I had in windows mobile and so far I love everything I've seen on the Evo in videos and screen shots. I just hope there are similar touches on the Evo like being able to turn on/off radios easily, being able to just start typing on a screen and have that launch the google search or browser URL, I've gotten really used to all the shortcuts in webOS.
No OS is perfect and I'm sure there will be many things I miss from webOS but I'm hoping there are just as many new things in Android that I'll like as well (the 50,000 app catalog is a start, although the webOS home brew community has been awesome, there's actually little that I need on my Pre that I lack).
Guess I'll know in a couple of weeks!
Last edited by jeffreytz; 05-17-2010 at 12:25 AM. Reason: Spelling
- 05-17-2010, 08:56 AM #55
- 05-17-2010, 12:55 PM #56
I have a launch week Pre and must be one of the lucky ones because I never had a problem with dead pixels, Oreo-ing, dead keyboards, bad battery life (after conditioning), and various other HW failures. The flimsy USB port door fell off after 9 months and I've got a small crack in the bezel, but those aren't severe problems.
In fact, the only serious problem I've had was with the TeleNav "account expired" error when trying to get a route in Sprint Nav and trying to get it fixed has taken me into the depths of Sprint CSR Hell which is why so many people hate Sprint. All my previous contacts were pleasant and efficient, but the 3-1/2 months - you read that right; MONTHS! - of banging my head against the wall in trying to it fixed w/o hard resetting my phone have filled me with a hatred for Sprint so deep that whenever their ads come on TV, my g/f covers her ears because she knows I'm about to bellow the 13-letter plural for someone akin to Oedipus at the TV. (Note: Only slight exaggeration.) If it wasn't the fact that Sprint is the hands-down bang-for-buck leader, I'd be outta there. However, I'm not about to spend Verizon money to spite Dan Hesse.
If Palm had been bought by HTC and we were likely to get a webOS phone on EVO hardware, I'd wager 85% of the people here talking about bailing would stick around. Unfortunately, all we've heard about is a tablet and nada about new phones. After another year of killer Android phones and whatever the iPhone 4 is like, what does HPalm expect to do; launch something at 2011 CES? Talk about being a year late and a million dollars short!
webOS is a wonderful OS with great potential trapped on a merely OK piece of hardware that managed to destroy itself out of the box one of the worst marketing campaigns ever. I swear, future marketing classes will study how a company desperate to make a lifesaving "Hail Mary" product launch of a revolutionary multi-tasking mobile OS decided that instead of showing the features - like ANY OTHER PHONE AD WOULD'VE, STARTING WITH THE IPHONE - they would have some creepy Borg Queen weirdo murmuring about how the phone was reading her mind and going, "Bing! Bing! Bing!" The fact that Palm to this day refuses to own that steaming pile of epic failness is why they're likely doomed to be a case study on how not to do things more than a leader in tech. Shame on them.
- 05-17-2010, 01:52 PM #57
- 0 Posts
I gave the Pre a chance.
To say that Palm messed up big time with the Pre is the understatement of the century.
First of all, they absolutely RUINED the PIM functionality that made the PalmOS the PalmOS. Todos, memos, calendars, the DESKTOP CLIENT, where a perfectly functioning ecosystem. By killing memo and todo syncing and then ruining the calendar by making it dog slow and harder to use, they instantly made me less productive than I was before.
I actually carry around pen and paper because I can't sync my damn todos anymore. Who on God's green earth thought to leave this feature out?
Second of all, the Pre hardware is terrible. Great design, nice keyboard, but a piece of junk with the worst battery life of any device I've ever owned.
I just got my 2nd pre (a refurb), and after only 2 weeks already has the stress fractures my launch day one did.
And the battery life. HOLY CRAP. Do you know many problems I've had where it's the end of the night and I can no longer use my phone? Or even times where I need to make a call, and I forgot to charge after work, and have to shut every feature down to eek a few more minutes of battery life. TERRIBLE. And to those who say to carry a 2nd battery. How in the world are you supposed to crack open the back of a pre while out at a bar, swap batteries and click everything together? Oh, and then wait 3 minutes for the damn thing to start again.
Sorry, Palm. The Pre was a great concept which was obliterated by execution. I really can't wait anymore. I need a device that actually acts like a next generation smartphone, and has the apps and performance and battery life I expect.
Sorry for ranting a bit on this, but since there are a lot of Pre owners considering the switch, I figured there will be a lot of nodding heads reading this.
Hopefully someone at Palm is reading this and has the power to bring threads like this back to the powers that be. The fact that none of these issues have been resolved a year after launch makes me think that they think the issues are elsewhere.
Simply put, if I had the PIM functionality of the Treo and decent battery life, I would not be buying an EVO 4G on launch day, and I'm sure there are hundreds, if not thousands of longtime customers who feel the same way.
- 05-21-2010, 02:38 PM #58
Another long term Palm USer. I go back to the Pilots, handsprings and all the Treos and Centros. 800W and was the first on line at my store at 2am for the PRE . But it never became the phone it was meant to be. the software is buggy, slow. the HArdware is horrible. And count me in as another user who loves WEB OS but Android seems to be the future. Keep living in the past and you get left behind.
- 05-21-2010, 06:07 PM #59
+1 to Pedro's rant.
The Pre was a great idea, great design, interesting OS....but it sucked, IMHO. It would do the mot ridiculous things...little things start to drive you nuts, like having to click the "end call" button two or three times before the sluggish OS realizes, "oh, my owner is trying to end a call."
Or...memory management...or lack thereof. Opening ONE SOLITARY CARD, and then getting the dreaded beep-beep tone, and your "smart" phone telling you that you have too many card open. Brilliant. (Like Pedro said, there's a lot of you nodding your heads right now.)
- 05-21-2010, 08:34 PM #60
- 06-04-2010, 10:54 PM #61
The sheer number of usernames I recognize here from PreCentral is amazing, including fr4nk1yn who made some of my favorite Pre themes (in what was largely a sea of crap).
I plan to join the ranks of the EVO owners on Monday, decommissioning my Pre for backup use only. (I walked into a Sprint store in downtown Chicago at opening on Friday only to discover they had already sold out and were optimistically hoping for a reallocation later in the day which never happened. Monday it is, I hope.)
webOS is second to none in terms of usability. But as people have noted, Palm had its head up its *** with regards to hardware and actually implementing polish and key functionality that was included in PalmOS. If it wasn't for the webOSinternals guys, homebrewers and themers, my opinion about webOS wouldn't be nearly as positive. The phone running at the stock 500Mhz is a bad joke after having the 800Mhz patch installed for the past 3 months and the phone STILL chugs way more often than it should even with the 800MHz patch. Still, the potential's there but I don't see HP as being smart enough to fully capitalize on it. My money's on webOS as we know and love it dying a slow, painful death despite what some overzealous Pretards who now seem to be dominating PreCentral seem to think (some of us think the Pre IS too small and don't wear skintight assless chaps so we can actually pocket an EVO).
Looking forward to exploring everything Android has to offer and hearing what people have to say here.
- 06-04-2010, 11:01 PM #62
- 06-08-2010, 02:15 PM #63
my workshop using an old post no one will ever notice...
Android Market To Hit 100,000 Apps on July 24th?
At the Droid X event on June 22, Google said that the Android Marketplace had hit 68,000 apps.
That's pretty impressive.
But looking at the tracking data from our friends at , that 68,000 app number may have been from June 1, 2010, not June 22nd when it was stated. And 21-day old data in the Android world is pretty old.
As of July 7, 2010, Androlib put the app count at 87,587 app with about 700 new apps being added each day. If you color outside the lines a bit as shown in red above, and do some quick math, it looks like Google may announce that Android has hit 100,000 apps around July 24th. As alwasy, these number include apps, skins, keyboards, etc.
100,000 Android Apps!
You heard it at Android|Central first!
Last edited by milominderbinder; 07-07-2010 at 01:49 PM.
- 06-13-2010, 10:58 PM #64
- 07-03-2010, 02:31 AM #65
- 07-16-2010, 01:10 PM #66
Another Pre Defector here... although I'm keeping mine handy in case I need to switch back.
Things I miss:
* true or should i say EASY multi-tasking
* copy and paste. That was sooooo easy to do, shift + tap = selected text copied! I don't want to copy the entire message!!! Guess I'll be on these forums a long time looking to do this.
* flicking cards away
* flicking between cards
* numeric lock screen
- 07-24-2010, 02:57 AM #67
Things I miss about the Pre and webos, wait I'm still thinking???????????????
Palm just announced that they will be coming out with webos 2.0 and a new device by the end of the year for those looking to return!
Last edited by kinster02; 07-24-2010 at 03:03 AM.