Group Message problem

[AC Question]

I recently broke my s4 so I went to best buy and I had a insurance program with them called the Black Tie Program... they will give me a new phone, I got the new s4 but now here is the problem. on my original s4 I would be able to send and receive group chats in one thread, now with this s4 I can send the group message in 1 thread but receive every message as a different thread

example:
ME: Hey
James: yo
Dylan: whats up

Now this:
ME: Hey

New Thread of James: Yo

so I get every message they send me like they are personally sending me a message and idk how to fix it I cant find an answer anywhere.

 

[Golfdriver97]

Perhaps there is a setting in Messages for Group messaging?