If the old battery charges in your phone, it's not the phone. If the new battery charges in other phones, it's not the battery.
This is one of those "I have to have the phone in my hands, and it's going to take a long time" repair jobs. I'd just try a battery from one of the other phones (I'm assuming they're all the same model - if they aren't, none of this entire thread makes any difference) - if it charges, ask for a replacement of the new battery. (If not, we're back to "it's a strange problem".)
05-27-2015 06:43 PM