I'm convinced that the EVO is just weird with battery usage on it's own. However I think I may have found a SOLUTION.
So out of the box the 1st week: Never experiencing any issues.
2nd week: Started getting bad battery results and last week just terrible with around 5-7 hours of regular use. I did a Factory Reset (DL'ed all my apps plus more as soon as I reset) and the next day got real good results. Even with good results about 10 hours of regular/good usage.
Post Update: Day 1: Got extremely good results, 13-14 hours of heavy usage.
DAY 2: Horrible, terrible results, loosing 30% in 1 hour when my phone was not even being used with nothing running. ( I should add to this that I did leave it on the charger after being fully charged, overnight).
DAY 3 (Today): Good usage and still going 24 hours (UPtime) strong. Have about 25% battery life left. Been texting all day, FriendStreaming etc.
MY G-Talk is always on I don't think that's a main problem.
My Sense (Big) Weather & Clock widget is always running.
I have Auto-Sync on all day.
Screen brightness of about 30%
I do NOT have a Task Killer installed (Didn't do nothing for me when I did install it anyway).
I really think it's all about how you charge it. Someone had mentioned on these forums that "After the phone is fully charged, if you leave it on the charger the phone stops charging and starts to drain even when still connected." Last night I actually made it charge for the 2-3 hours it takes to fully charge and took it right off the charger, went to sleep and woke up this morning and didn't loose a single fraction on the battery indicator on top. Like I said right now it shows 24 hours since it came off the charger and now 20% battery life left.
Try doing what I've tried and report back and see if this helps. Let me/us know, please. Hope this helps.