You missed my point. Earlier your examples were on specific models and that is what I was addressing. You're right, the Pre didn't hurt Assurion overall, but if you looked at just the Pre in microcosm I bet it did -- they most likely paid out more than they took in. Of course they made up for this on other models where they took in way more than they paid out. I only look at the bottom line when it comes to insurance comapnies, and determine for myself if they are providing a true and accurate service, or if they are ripping myself and others off in the process. When it's the latter, I scream really loud as I believe we need comprehensive insurance change in this country, just like Tort Reform.
So, are your really saying that Assurion is sharing their data of your claims with other insurance companies? So if I claim a phone loss my auto insurance rates are going to go up? I find this hard to believe.... ALL Insurance companies have the same data they can look at BEFORE issuing a policy to you. It is the Insurable Risk Database. I don't know their actual name for the database, but if you file ANY insurance claim, it goes in there, and ALL insurance companies can look at it. Most do when they are selling you an auto insurance policy. If you already have one, you're probably safe unless you start getting tickets, or get in a wreck they have to pay for...then they will look in there see you can't drive, can't even walk and carry a cell phone, so they will take your rates as high as they can in hopes you pay or move soemwhere else so they don't have to insure you. Insurance likes to TAKE money, not dole it out. You can't debate my numbers I gave you when you said I pay the say amount for other insurances, so you are arguing semantics?
If you don't have it, what does it matter to you if it goes up to $16 a month?