[spinachie]

I have an S7 Edge and it's a great phone, but have the opportunity to upgrade to a G6 or S8 (S8 will be about 200 more expensive.

I liked my G5, but battery was a little lower than expected and found a great deal for S7 Edge ( )

What I love about G6 compared to S8:

Fingerprint scanner position
Wide camera lens
I can use a glass screen protector with full clarity (rather than naked or 'film' screen protector which makes screen clarity poor)
Price

What I love about S8 compared to G6:

LOVE the design.
I like the curved screen
Iris scanner
64GB native storage vs 32GB (native is always better for me)

I am a bit worried about battery life, which do you think will do better?

If price wasn't an issue, would you still choose G6?

Thanks!!

[TylerLV76]

I have an S7 Edge and it's a great phone, but have the opportunity to upgrade to a G6 or S8 (S8 will be about 200 more expensive.

I liked my G5, but battery was a little lower than expected and found a great deal for S7 Edge ( )

What I love about G6 compared to S8:

Fingerprint scanner position
Wide camera lens
I can use a glass screen protector with full clarity (rather than naked or 'film' screen protector which makes screen clarity poor)
Price

What I love about S8 compared to G6:

LOVE the design.
I like the curved screen
Iris scanner
64GB native storage vs 32GB (native is always better for me)

I am a bit worried about battery life, which do you think will do better?

If price wasn't an issue, would you still choose G6?

Thanks!!

Having had both and the S8+ I feel pretty comfortable commenting on the battery in terms of my experiences.

G6 - 6 1/2 hours consistently
S8 - Lately I've been hitting 7 hours consistently but have dipped down to 6 hours on occasion.
S8+ - 8 1/2 hours consistently but got rid of it after a week.

Only you can decide which one looks better but the G6 is quite possibly the most comfortable device on the market currently. It is an absolute joy to hold in the hand.

The only reason I don't have the G6 anymore was due to helping someone out in a bad situation. Otherwise I would be using both devices regularly.

[nathdogg1985]

Regardless of price (even though the G6 wasn't much cheaper then S8 in the UK) I would choose the G6 over the S8. For me the S8 wasn't even a consideration with only the curved screen available, I really don't like them at all and feel they add nothing. This is just personal preference though, I know just as many people like yourself like the curved screen.

As for battery life, I'm very happy with my G6. I can often make it through the day with mixed usage and still have over 30% remaining. Obviously that will vary from user to user, but the general consensus is positive overall. I can't personally comment about the S8 but I believe the battery is at least comparable to the G6.

[Impenneteri]

One con of the G6 also is that it doesn't wake up when a notification comes up even for Messaging.

IMO, the wakeup feature is important especially when you place your phone in a desk beside you and if the notification is important that you need to reply immediately or something you can attend to later.

[Jeremiah Bonds]

G6 battery life is WAY better than G5 battery life.

[zipro]

S8 has a faster processor but is very much prone to lagging. I had to reboot mine every other day because it would slow down so bad

[spinachie]

Thanks for the great replies

One con of the G6 also is that it doesn't wake up when a notification comes up even for Messaging.

IMO, the wakeup feature is important especially when you place your phone in a desk beside you and if the notification is important that you need to reply immediately or something you can attend to later.

Whoa, I never knew this. Isn't this the whole point of a phone these days? Is there nothing that can be done to alter this in settings?

[TylerLV76]

Thanks for the great replies



Whoa, I never knew this. Isn't this the whole point of a phone these days? Is there nothing that can be done to alter this in settings?

Textra will wake the screen.

My S8 also doesn't wake up for alot of notifications. Email for example, just makes a noise but you do have a LED that flashes.

I think most companies are relying on the Always ON Display.

[lightrules]

If price wasn't an issue, would you still choose G6?

Yes I would. Like others have said, I don't like curved screens. You mention screen protectors, I only use tempered glass. The G6 has an in-hand feel that is SO nice. As for Iris scanner, do people REALLY use it? Seems FPS is way more popular/useful/secure. I think it comes down to 2 things for the S8: design and AMOLED. If those aren't huge points for you, the G6 is 2nd to none IMHO. And man, that wide angle lens (both front and rear) is so practical, hard to go back to anything else. As for notifications, AOD is enough for me.

[Jeremiah Bonds]

I have an S7 Edge and it's a great phone, but have the opportunity to upgrade to a G6 or S8 (S8 will be about 200 more expensive.

I liked my G5, but battery was a little lower than expected and found a great deal for S7 Edge ( )

What I love about G6 compared to S8:

Fingerprint scanner position
Wide camera lens
I can use a glass screen protector with full clarity (rather than naked or 'film' screen protector which makes screen clarity poor)
Price

What I love about S8 compared to G6:

LOVE the design.
I like the curved screen
Iris scanner
64GB native storage vs 32GB (native is always better for me)

I am a bit worried about battery life, which do you think will do better?

If price wasn't an issue, would you still choose G6?

Thanks!!

If price wasn't an issue I'd still choose the G6. I got it at full price on release day

[TwitchyPuppy]

LG G6 hands down!

[nathdogg1985]

Thanks for the great replies



Whoa, I never knew this. Isn't this the whole point of a phone these days? Is there nothing that can be done to alter this in settings?

You can always use the always on display as an option, it will display notifications.

[Qc_Anubis]

I've owned the s8+ since about launch got a g6 today,i'll say this the iris scanner is not worth your money it's more of a bandage solution to the finger sensor being in an odd place. The 64 BG is nice if you need it but you can use a micro sd card on both.Curved screens are fragile as hell too,so if you're the type of person that drops their phone again not worth it,specially since i've heard mostly bad about glass protector for the s8 since you know.... it's curved. Overall it is an incredible device to use and samsung's amoled never cease to amaze me. But i went for the g6 mostly since their UI is still less heavy than samsung's own+ i didn't need adb to get my mobile data shortcut on mine xD so it's a + for me. Oh should also mention if you use headphones alot get the g6 the quality you can get is ameizing !

[vasekvi]

Amoled display burn in alone is reason enough for me to choose G6 over S8. Every single Samsung phone I've ever owned suffers from screen burn in. Yes I use Waze and I spend alot of time driving, but it's a real issue for me so Amoled is out of the question.

[dov1978]

One con of the G6 also is that it doesn't wake up when a notification comes up even for Messaging.

IMO, the wakeup feature is important especially when you place your phone in a desk beside you and if the notification is important that you need to reply immediately or something you can attend to later.

This bugged me too til I installed an app in the PlayStore calls Screen Notifications by Luke Korth. It wakes the screen for 10 secs (or whatever you set it to) and shows your notifications on the lockscreen pretty much identically as the iPhone does if you're familiar with that. It made a massive difference to my G6.

I still miss my G6, I had an s8 Plus then the G6 then back to regular s8 which I have now. The G6 was tonnes more comfortable to hold, had better call quality, great wide angle camera, better manual camera controls, dark theme, better FPS, double tap to wake,
Things I prefer on the s8 are slightly better rear camera (and faster which is very important if you have young kids or pets to snap), much better front camera, notification led, slightly better AOD thanks to the Amoled screen, Iris scanner, one handed mode, slightly better battery life. I'm sure I've missed a few from both but whatever you choose you'll be happy

[Jeremiah Bonds]

This bugged me too til I installed an app in the PlayStore calls Screen Notifications by Luke Korth. It wakes the screen for 10 secs (or whatever you set it to) and shows your notifications on the lockscreen pretty much identically as the iPhone does if you're familiar with that. It made a massive difference to my G6.

I still miss my G6, I had an s8 Plus then the G6 then back to regular s8 which I have now. The G6 was tonnes more comfortable to hold, had better call quality, great wide angle camera, better manual camera controls, dark theme, better FPS, double tap to wake,
Things I prefer on the s8 are slightly better rear camera (and faster which is very important if you have young kids or pets to snap), much better front camera, notification led, slightly better AOD thanks to the Amoled screen, Iris scanner, one handed mode, slightly better battery life. I'm sure I've missed a few from both but whatever you choose you'll be happy

I was wondering where you were. Lol

[dov1978]

I was wondering where you were. Lol

I may well be back yet lol

[Jeremiah Bonds]

I may well be back yet lol

I'll welcome you with open arms.

[trucksmoveamerica#AC]

Amoled display burn in alone is reason enough for me to choose G6 over S8. Every single Samsung phone I've ever owned suffers from screen burn in. Yes I use Waze and I spend alot of time driving, but it's a real issue for me so Amoled is out of the question.

And every Samsung phone I've owned, my wife owned, my kids owned, parents owned, friends owned have NOT ever gotten screen burn in. Don't know what to say, but that's a lot of phones with no burn in

[trucksmoveamerica#AC]

You know asking this question in the lg G6 forum your going to get biased answers. Ask the same question in the S8 forum and you'll get biased answers towards the S8. Get the phone that works for you, like there is no one phone that is right for everyone. Both G6 and S8 phones are good phones.

By the way, I've gotten over 15 hours on my S8 plus, and I've never done that with any other phone.

[nathdogg1985]

And every Samsung phone I've owned, my wife owned, my kids owned, parents owned, friends owned have NOT ever gotten screen burn in. Don't know what to say, but that's a lot of phones with no burn in

I've also suffered screen burn on my previous Samsung device (Galaxy S6), it certainly does exist.

It really comes down to how you use the phone. Sat Navs seem to be the main culprit as the screen can be stuck on the same image (Notification bar, buttons etc) for hours. Personally I like to use my phone as a Sat Nav so the G6 having an LCD screen is something I welcome. I'm now reluctant to consider a phone with an AMOLED display, although Samsung made that easy by only releasing a curved screen. I guess it's like the saying, "once bitten, twice shy".

[Almeuit]

I've also suffered screen burn on my previous Samsung device (Galaxy S6), it certainly does exist.

It really comes down to how you use the phone. Sat Navs seem to be the main culprit as the screen can be stuck on the same image (Notification bar, buttons etc) for hours. Personally I like to use my phone as a Sat Nav so the G6 having an LCD screen is something I welcome. I'm now reluctant to consider a phone with an AMOLED display, although Samsung made that easy by only releasing a curved screen. I guess it's like the saying, "once bitten, twice shy".

It def does -- but there are people with old LG phones that have shown some horrid screen retention as well.. I believe most phones after a good amount of use can have it happen. Also depends on the user. My timeout is 1 minute so my phone never sits on a static image for an extended time.

[trucksmoveamerica#AC]

I've also suffered screen burn on my previous Samsung device (Galaxy S6), it certainly does exist.

It really comes down to how you use the phone. Sat Navs seem to be the main culprit as the screen can be stuck on the same image (Notification bar, buttons etc) for hours. Personally I like to use my phone as a Sat Nav so the G6 having an LCD screen is something I welcome. I'm now reluctant to consider a phone with an AMOLED display, although Samsung made that easy by only releasing a curved screen. I guess it's like the saying, "once bitten, twice shy".

I'm not saying it doesn't happen, my point was I've had several and I mean several Samsung devices with zero burn in screens, the one I was replying to made it sound like it happens all the time easily. As someone else said, you have to have the screen on for long periods of time with nothing moving. My screen time out is set at 30 seconds. Can it happen under normal usage I suppose possible but unlikely IMO.

[ffejjj]

I've seen my friends S7 with bad burn in and my daughter's G5 started showing signs of retention within a month...

I have personally never had an oled screen. Just like LCD better but this go around the 2 phones I'm looking at are the V30 and the Pixel XL 2, both presumably with amoled screens.

[Qc_Anubis]

This bugged me too til I installed an app in the PlayStore calls Screen Notifications by Luke Korth. It wakes the screen for 10 secs (or whatever you set it to) and shows your notifications on the lockscreen pretty much identically as the iPhone does if you're familiar with that. It made a massive difference to my G6.

I still miss my G6, I had an s8 Plus then the G6 then back to regular s8 which I have now. The G6 was tonnes more comfortable to hold, had better call quality, great wide angle camera, better manual camera controls, dark theme, better FPS, double tap to wake,
Things I prefer on the s8 are slightly better rear camera (and faster which is very important if you have young kids or pets to snap), much better front camera, notification led, slightly better AOD thanks to the Amoled screen, Iris scanner, one handed mode, slightly better battery life. I'm sure I've missed a few from both but whatever you choose you'll be happy

Battery life wise that's always subjective i bet some can get better life out of their g6 than others with an s8+ (i'm one of them and i owned an s8+ before) though i thought the g6 had a notification light but guess i wasen't so crazy. But i hate when my screen goes on everytime i get a notification on my s8 i was streaming music and more often than not it would turn on in my pockets and change songs by itself which was annoying af ! But like you said both are good choices people just gotta learn to use what they like the most.