Well, most reviews have praised it. You can either go with the assessment from The Verge that you copied in the opening post, in which case you should not buy the phone. Alternatively, you can go with the positive reviews, get the phone and see for yourself. Personally, having played with the phone a few times I will say that, while it is not as good as Samsung, saying it is generations behind Samsung is a bit of a stretch. Furthermore, other reviews of final units have similarly concluded that it is an excellent screen, but not up to Samsung's. I even came across one that concluded that the V30's screen was better than the GS8.
I am not going to judge the review from The Verge. But I will also rely on other reviews before making a decision.