For removing the screen, that's not a reasonable price, it's a giveaway price. Just removing the screen should cost more. Then replacing the board with the port (which is pretty cheap) and replacing the screen - around here, they charge about $80. And this is a town full of soldiers, not the wealthiest customers around.
@
firemanc4: Running the battery down to 0% is a good way to kill it - I'm surprised that it lasted this long. Rule of thumb, backed up by Cadex, the largest maker of battery testing equipment in the world -
never discharge the battery to below 40%. (And recent studies have shown that we shouldn't charge them to more than about 80-85%.) Lithium aren't the best battery choice there is, but they're the lightest ones, and that's what everyone wants, so that's what everyone gets. (I wouldn't mind carrying a Gel-cel in by pocket, with a cable to feed the phone. Heavy (lead) but you can discharge it to 0 without harming it, and you can charge it to 100%. And a reasonably sized Gel-cel would give you very heavy usage for a week between charges.)