Started with Otterbox Commuter. Protective but really bulky. Traded it for Otterbox Symmetry. Not bad but still too bulky.
Last eight months, I use a Spigen Ultra thin case. Perfect! Grippy, thin, haven't dropped it so can't comment on protection
I carry the phone and Spigen in leather belt holster. Excellent combo. Am sticking with this because... it works for me.