IMHO all of the "rugged" cases offering superior protection have those raised lips to prevent any scratches when laying the phone screen down, one can actually see this in your photos. Thanks for those by the way, I have been eyeing the Tactical Evo XT by Tech 21, but the rather high price tag as well as the fact payment methods offered here in my country are a bit difficult for me.
So far I got the often quoted Unicorn Beetle Pro case since I got the phone and am really using it since I received my replacement phone (which is said to have a good battery now) last week. IMHO the case is pretty good for the price. It is bulky, yes but pretty sturdy. It is difficult getting the phone in for the first time and even more difficult getting it out of the case - however that ensures it stays in the case after a heavy drop. I am not sure though just how much protection it *really* offers, the rather hard rubber sidings aren't really thick and the hard back also won't offer much absorbtion from a heavy drop. For everything else it's just fine, I especially like the big opening for the S-Pen, very good access there, something which would concern me about the Tactical Evo XT, the opening there seems to be pretty small. The door covers by the way are a bit too stiff for my taste, but maybe they'll loosen up over time.
If you want a good bang for the buck and want a case for heavier protection, I think the Unicorn Beetle Pro is a very decent choice. Thanks to the two-piece construnction it also seems to be pretty screen protector friendly, not sure about thicker tempered glass ones though - my wet applied plastic film protector is fine.