Do you think the Galaxy s II will get ice cream? (The one that mixes gingerbread and honeycomb features)
Judging on previous upgrade history, no. I'm gonna be optimistic though and say I think Samsung has learned its lesson.
If it comes out in September, I think it will.
What previous history? The Galaxy S1 launching with Eclair, and if your not in the US getting Froyo? We don't even know that the Galaxy S1 won't get gingerbread (I'd be surprised if we didn't) since not a single phone has gotten that upgrade.
But we ARE in the US.
But we ARE in the US. The reality is that Samsung has only delivered an official Froyo update to one version of the GS1 on any of the major carriers. And IMHO that's only because they came out with a newer version. All conspiracy theories aside (because I don't care if it's Sammy's or the carriers fault) they haven't been updated.
I would love to think that this phone will have a good update cycle because I'm honestly very interested in it. The processor is fast (any dual core is fast) and the screen is amazing. The one thing that keeps me away from Samsung is there track record with support AFTER the phone has been released.
Judging on previous upgrade history, no. I'm gonna be optimistic though and say I think Samsung has learned its lesson.
You ARE on Android Central
You ARE an enthusiast
You ARE running a custom rom
Every single version of the Galaxy S has had full release quality builds of froyo out for some time (possibly barring the fascinate) that haven't released yet. Those builds are complete, with roms galore and easily flashed. So what's your point? Samsung has the releases done, I don't blame them. If you bought the phone, you'd flash them too.
I'm not sure why you're being so hard on Sammy for it's update track record when considering it was mainly a carrier delay, and also when you're running a custom ROM, even if they updated in a more timely manner wouldnt you yourself just run a custom ROM? :-D
Correct me if I'm wrong (because that has been known to happen) but Froyo ROM's didn't start showing up until a leaked version of the update came out, right? And the Fascinate has one of (if not THE) best Froyo leak to happen yet. It's stable and makes it seem like everything's ready to go.
Because in order to get all of the features of the latest version of Android you need to have a stock version of the ROM to work with. Otherwise it's kinda just a cobbled together version that will have some big issues.
I'm running Cyanogen 7 right now. I have an HTC made myTouch 4G. As long as I keep running Cyanogen I will have the latest version of Android soon after Google releases source. Heck the Nexus 1 still doesn't have an official version yet. So for me right now updates aren't important. That wouldn't be the case if Samsung makes the GSII the same way as the original. Cyanogen isn't officially porting to it yet for reasons beyond my understanding (something about the weird bootloader I think) which makes official updates EXTREMELY important for me. Yes, I will root and flash what I want to get what I want, but I need a phone that's capable of that in the first place.
And to be fair I would be just as hard on any manufacturer (I'm looking straight at you Sony) for not updating phones that were promised an update. Actually in that particular case Sony is worse than Samsung. Motorola isn't terrible but HTC has by far the best track record with getting official updates out.
I'm running Cyanogen 7 right now. I have an HTC made myTouch 4G. As long as I keep running Cyanogen I will have the latest version of Android soon after Google releases source. Heck the Nexus 1 still doesn't have an official version yet. So for me right now updates aren't important. That wouldn't be the case if Samsung makes the GSII the same way as the original. Cyanogen isn't officially porting to it yet for reasons beyond my understanding (something about the weird bootloader I think) which makes official updates EXTREMELY important for me. Yes, I will root and flash what I want to get what I want, but I need a phone that's capable of that in the first place.
You are correct, they didn't start until a leaked version came out (October 1st for the captivate, earlier for the international). Shortly after that, it officially came out for the international version. The captivate, the vibrant, and the international have been rock solid for quite some time, with several leaks. I cannot say for sure about the other two, as I don't have them, and the roms aren't cross compatible like the other three. They may or may not be so solid.
CM still isn't a daily driver for the SGS, but that's not saying that the other roms are "cobbled together" with "big issues". Until 2 months ago, I was running a non-CM rom with the latest OS and features.
Cobbled together was a poor choice of words. But from what I hear without an "official" leak (if that makes any sense LOL) it's extremely difficult to develop for it. Maybe I should've said "patched together" instead. I've had enough conversations with enough dev's to know that sometimes it's all trial and error and sometimes things don't work the way they are supposed to because of something the manufacturer did.
Correct me if I'm wrong (because that has been known to happen) but Froyo ROM's didn't start showing up until a leaked version of the update came out, right? And the Fascinate has one of (if not THE) best Froyo leak to happen yet. It's stable and makes it seem like everything's ready to go.
Because in order to get all of the features of the latest version of Android you need to have a stock version of the ROM to work with. Otherwise it's kinda just a cobbled together version that will have some big issues.
I'm running Cyanogen 7 right now. I have an HTC made myTouch 4G. As long as I keep running Cyanogen I will have the latest version of Android soon after Google releases source. Heck the Nexus 1 still doesn't have an official version yet. So for me right now updates aren't important. That wouldn't be the case if Samsung makes the GSII the same way as the original. Cyanogen isn't officially porting to it yet for reasons beyond my understanding (something about the weird bootloader I think) which makes official updates EXTREMELY important for me. Yes, I will root and flash what I want to get what I want, but I need a phone that's capable of that in the first place.
And to be fair I would be just as hard on any manufacturer (I'm looking straight at you Sony) for not updating phones that were promised an update. Actually in that particular case Sony is worse than Samsung. Motorola isn't terrible but HTC has by far the best track record with getting official updates out.
With the international S2 having all of at&t's bands, I would think it would be a little easier getting an update. Hopefully at&t's won't be much different from the international version. Unless we fall under a region that gets a different processor.