The Active appeals to some for different reasons such as inclusion of design choices removed from the GS6 and having dedicated physical buttons instead of capacitive buttons. In the past, some of these features appealed to me as well. To others, it's design, from an aesthetic and functional perspective is a throwback to a design that was historically successful and given the improvements and functionality of the GS6, they aren't missed. Really, how often if you don't work in a harsh environment are you rally going to need the Active. The arrangement if the key on the front are, to me anyways, analogous to the different between analog and digital gauges. The home button has a functional purpose as part of the fingerprint scanner. Dimensionally, isn't it larger making it more bulky, something the GS6 moved away from? Isn't the Active an AT&T exclusive? In the end, buy whatever works for you no matter how it looks.