I used to use Android Messages (Google messenger) in my other phones but sticking to stock messages app on the S8+ because it gives me option to mark the message as read in pop up notifications which is super useful to me.
What bug? Im using android messages and i dont think i have a problem.Textra used to be my go to app a while ago. Then I went with Android (Google) messenger. I don't care for all the customization stuff anymore. But stock messaging apps on Android flagships are pretty good now including the one on this device. Only wish it had gif supoort. Once Android messages fix the MMS over WiFi bug then I will probably go back to that. So the top 3 options I suggest in no particular order:
1. Samsung stock
2. Android messages
3. Textra
Usually a big fan of Textra but liking the stock app better on the S8 plus.
I've tried a bunch of different messaging apps and I always end up going back to stock. There are some native features that can only be achieved with the stock messaging app. For example, when you click in your photo gallery to find a picture to send and hit share, your most common contacts will come right up or you can select the messaging app. With a third party app, you can't select the common contacts. You have to choose the app and then select the contact. It's a minor thing but I like that feature.
I was using Handcent for a while and I love the customization. To each his own but I hate the way Textra looks. It's just boring flat colors. I like to be able to set images as my background in my messages. With Handcent you can do this on the contact level so you can have a different image background for each contact. You can also link it to your computer and text right from your computer. As far as customization goes, I think Handcent is king. The problem with it is that it is really heavy handed (probably because of the level of customization options).
I get the most common contacts pop up for textra when I go to share things from other apps. Exactly what you've described. I don't think that's really limited to the stock messaging app, it's just that not every third party app supports it yet.
You got me thinking about handcent now. Something about Textra def has me bored lately. Could just be me though, I get bored easily when it comes to certain things lol
Oh that's good to know. I know with Handcent it wasn't doing that. At least it wasn't with my S7 Edge and V20 anyway. I never really got too far with Textra because I just hated the bland look of it. Functionality wise, it's awesome. I just really like to have a background, like I said.
Handcent is crazy as far as customization, like I mentioned. It also has delayed sending and you can set it to send messages in the future so you won't forget birthdays and whatnot. It's worth checking out. It's a little heavy handed though. It's slightly slower opening up for the first time after it's been cleared from the recent apps but it is a nice app.
Yea I have experience with Handcent from a few years ago but always came back to Textra. I'm sure it's changed considerably since then, though it's no surprise it's still a heavy app. It's always been amongst the top customizable texting apps. I love that you can customize literally everything, but that's a bit overwhelming sometimes, so it could tend to discourage some people from learning/using the app. Not saying that's what happened with me, but just saying...
Have you tried YAATA yet? It's crazy customizable, just like handcent, but if my memory serves I believe it was still a speedy application to use.
I concur with Textra. Though it has some bugs using it with T-Mobile. But there is a setting specifically for T-Mobile and that seems to resolve it. There are still some issues, but the stock app also has the same bugs so I'm assuming those are on their end. I've been using the stock app on my s7 and now my s8 for better gear s3 integration, but it seems I haven't really used any of the features I gain on the watch from using the stock app. I may switch back soon. The stock app on phone is a bit frustrating.