GNex vs. S3 (opinions)

TBolt2011

Well-known member
Jan 23, 2011
700
65
0
Okay, so obviously the hardware performance aspect of this goes to the S3. I know that, and I'm not looking to debate the hardware facts except for your opinions on a couple of those facts.

What I'm mainly looking at is the price difference, the fact that there will be no Nexus 4 on Verizon (not that I'm impressed with it enough to buy it anyways), the battery life and how much expandable batteries help without totally bulking the phone up, the camera quality, and the 16gb storage limit. I plan on rooting and doing all of the fun things that follow regardless of the choice, although I've heard you lose a lot of new exciting features on the S3 with custom ROMs.

First of all, the price. $49 vs $199. The price tag of the S3 is one that I CAN afford if that's the decision, but why spend $150 more than I have to if I end up liking the GNex more? I'm extremely happy with stock Android on my Nexus 7, and have never been a fan of TouchWiz while playing with any Samsung phone.

Now, I've been reading a lot of negativity about the Nexus being on Verizon. Slower-than-Google updates, oddities with LTE working properly, etc. Maybe not having the Nexus 4 on Verizon is a sign that it's just not a fit for the line of devices to be on this Network. How bad are the supposed issues that people are talking about with the phone on this network?

Next, the camera and lack of storage expansion. The camera, while only 5mp, was supposed to be very good for low-light settings (reported before the release, if I remember correctly), but nothing more than average otherwise. I will say right away that the camera isn't make or break because I don't use it to capture species-ending historic moments, but I am curious of the quality people are seeing from it. I have a Thunderbolt now, and I'm pleased with the camera on that. As for the SD Card... I realize that Nexus devices are "supposed" to lack this, and it's completely normal for the storage not to be expandable. But I'm not a fan of the Cloud yet. I'm not convinced that relying on someone else to store my stuff is a reliable way of listening to music or watching videos, etc. I do have Google Music and that is an option (as opposed to putting 10gb of music physically on my phone), but I prefer for that to be a back up as opposed to my source of listening to music.

So I'm really just looking for all of your opinions on these things, as well as anything else you'd have to add. I have an upgrade available on Nov. 17th.

Thanks!
 
If you plan to root.. then the only things you need to decide on are hardware.. the RAZR m has the specs of the gs3 including SD micro card slot. Incredible battery life. Perfect size. Gorilla glass. Water proofing and Kevlar backing. And GPS and radio signal much better then anything Samsung offers.. take a look. I'm just trying to help some people out.
 
If you plan to root.. then the only things you need to decide on are hardware.. the RAZR m has the specs of the gs3 including SD micro card slot. Incredible battery life. Perfect size. Gorilla glass. Water proofing and Kevlar backing. And GPS and radio signal much better then anything Samsung offers.. take a look. I'm just trying to help some people out.

Fair enough, a suggestion is a suggestion. When Google got Moto, did they start unlocking bootloaders? I know that was always an issue for rooters in the past (at least up until the DX as far as I know).
 
Fair enough, a suggestion is a suggestion. When Google got Moto, did they start unlocking bootloaders? I know that was always an issue for rooters in the past (at least up until the DX as far as I know).

not sure.. but I do know that motoblur was what kept me away from them for a long time. after almost a year on the nexus.. I can honestly say this OS feels like stock, or if anything a slightly improved stock.

I'm sure the answer is out there with a google search, i'm going to guess the bootloaders aren't locked like they use to be.

found this:

http://www.droid-life.com/2012/09/0...eloper-editions-to-bootloader-unlock-program/

looks like they are part of motorolas developer editions bootloader unlock program.. so yes.
 
I had the same concern about expandable memory and the Galaxy Nexus but it had 32gb on board and that has been more than enough for me. Wifi to a PC allows for fast transfers and 4G LTE allows the Cloud to actually work real well. Since the current Galaxy Nexus does not have 32gb and was knocked back to 16gb. I would hunt for an older model or go with the S3.
 

Trending Posts

Forum statistics

Threads
957,378
Messages
6,972,660
Members
3,163,780
Latest member
RohitPatidar57