Well here in the Nexus S forums most will probably say go with the Nexus S. I say try both devices, go to a store that has them, and see which one you like the most. If you are in no hurry to get a new phone then I suggest to wait because a new Nexus phone will probably come out sometime during November or December. If you really want a new phone like now then the Nexus S might be a better choice but you should still try both of them before you make your decision.