I like it. I think it'll be nice to have something that will responsive the vast majority of the time. I have the Skyrocket and there are times that I get no response no matter how many times I touch the capactive buttons.
stated numerous times, prefer it. That way, 3 yr old won't close netflix so easily on car trips. Have to use wife's iPhone every time because one of her fingers inevitably hit one of the capacitive buttons to close it.
I found it a bit of a challenge to orientate my GSII when I first got it...I'd go to pick it up and a lot of times it would be upside down because there wasn't button on either end of it to differentiate it. Kind of annoying, but I got use to it.
I prefer to have a physical button, but at the same time I know physical buttons come with a risk of them wearing out. But I like the idea of having a physical home button again