I hope so, because I'm hoping to use the new car dock feature in froyo (although I have a slight preference for landscape mode when navigating).
What car dock feature do you speak of?
I don't know which one was advertised in the Best Buy mag, but I've seen a couple of things speculating that it would be available in September. Like this one:
EVO 4G's Froyo features detailed in pictures, car dock coming in September? -- Engadget
I hope so, because I'm hoping to use the new car dock feature in froyo (although I have a slight preference for landscape mode when navigating).
Might want to read about the car dock before you spend the cash.
HTC EVO 4G car dock lands at Sprint stores -- Engadget Mobile
I agree with the poster above. The car dock allows the device to be fully functional, I don't know why tech sites say that it isn't. The phone fits snug in it. I have never had a car dock before, but I am really starting to enjoy it. It is a little pricey, but I think that it is worth it. Car panel mode in landscape would be a nice alternative, but it isn't really important to me.
They probably say that because the phone's SD card is not mountable as a mass-storage device, when using this dock.No clue why they say it's not mountable????
They probably say that because the phone's SD card is not mountable as a mass-storage device, when using this dock.
Here's how to demonstrate this for yourself:
Use a USB cable to connect your Evo to a PC. When given the choice, mount the phone as a storage device. Once mounted, browse the contents of your SD card from your PC. Play songs found there, etc. Satisfy yourself that everything is working, then disconnect.
Now, insert your phone into the dock. Using the same USB cable as above, connect the dock to your PC. Attempt to mount the SD card as a storage device.
Presumably, you will fail. But maybe you are correct, and the rest of the internet is wrong! I hope so. Let me know how it goes.
The wording isn't very clear, but it is not "incorrect". Let's go with "misleading".I think the "Wording" of the reviews and information of the car dock are incorrect. They make it sound as if you can't access your SD card when the phone is hooked to the dock...
No one. The review doesn't say a thing about computers. I mentioned using a computer, because that's the easiest way to test whether the dock prevents the phone from being recognized as a storage device. I didn't know you had a USB head-unit. Sorry if I muddied the issue even further.I think the reason it's worded wrong is, How many people are going to have their phone in the car dock and then hooked to a computer at the same time accessing their files on the SD card from the computer?
Now some cars (like mine) actually have a USB port on the dash and you could while in the dock plug the phone directly into your stereo (Which allows me to charge the phone) but you can't access the SD card this way...
The wording isn't very clear, but it is not "incorrect". Let's go with "misleading".The reviews just say that the phone (or the phone's SD card) "isn't mountable", while docked. "Mount" is short for "mount the phone on some host, as a storage device". It has nothing at all to do with using phone to access its own SD card. Obviously, a dock is going to have no effect on that sort of thing.
I do agree that the whole can't-be-mounted thing doesn't prevent music from being played. It just prevents it from being played in a particular way. Here's Engadget's fractured syntax:
Of course, nothing's perfect and judging from some posts we've seen, the dock does have its failings: the camera is covered by the plastic, the SD card isn't mountable while in the dock so listening to your stored tunes won't happen -- if you want to plug it into your head unit, for example -- and maybe the biggest foible, no charging cable is included.Shudder. Who thought that sentence was a good idea?
No one. The review doesn't say a thing about computers. I mentioned using a computer, because that's the easiest way to test whether the dock prevents the phone from being recognized as a storage device. I didn't know you had a USB head-unit. Sorry if I muddied the issue even further.
And, there you go! That's what they are talking about. The act of plugging your phone directly into a stereo, so the stereo can browse and play files directly from the phone, is called... "Mounting". And apparently, it doesn't work if you use this dock. Thank you for confirming that fact.
Now me, I don't have one of those fancy stereos. Most people don't. But, I guess this omission is a big deal to those that do.
(The reason that bluetooth is in no way a direct replacement for "mounting" is related to sound quality. Having the phone play a sound file, re-digitize the audio, and then send that data out over a low bandwidth bluetooth link, so the stereo can re-convert it to audio and amplify it, is very unlikely to sound as good as just having the stereo play the original sound file its own dang self. The same goes, to a lesser degree, for running a wire from the headphone jack to an AUX input: Leave the sound generation to the device that is purpose-built to do it. The phone might suck at one or more parts of it.)
(Again, I think I'd be fine with bluetooth audio. I figure it'll sound better than the weak FM stations I get now.)