HTC One (M8) GPe: Can you explain the benefits of stock Android?

blackdogAC

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2012
442
0
0
Visit site
Here I am on an old gingerbread device... and considering the M8. If I opt for the GPE, I get timely android updates when available and I avoid carrier bloatware. So a few questions...

What features besides Blinkfeed would a GPE lose?

What is the bloatware on an ATT M8? Does it really suck that much?

Is Sense6 that bad or is stock KitKat that good?

Just trying to make an informed decision. Thanks for any help.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

B. Diddy

Senior Ambassador
Moderator
Mar 9, 2012
165,946
5,255
113
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

Welcome to Android Central! I don't have an HTC phone, but my preference is always for vanilla Android or something close to it (like Motoblur). Personally, I'd rather not have a skin that foists various features on me that I'm not necessarily interested in, and can't uninstall. A lot of those extra features often take up a significant amount of internal storage--Samsung is notorious for this, with the OS, TouchWiz, and other preinstalled bloatware taking up about 7 GB of internal storage on the Galaxy S3 and S4, meaning that the 16 GB phone actually had only about 9 GB of storage available to the user. But don't get me wrong--those extra features (be it from Samsung or HTC or whoever) can be quite useful for certain people, and so it's definitely a personal preference thing.
 

Golfdriver97

Trusted Member Team Leader
Moderator
Dec 4, 2012
35,380
127
63
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

At one time I didn't like Vanilla Android either. It had to be TouchWiz, I wouldn't have anything to do with any thing else. That was less than a year ago, now it is the exact opposite. I won't have anything to do with a skinned version of Android.

Most of the carrier versions of phones often have tons of bloatware, with the Galaxy and Note series being very overweight. B. Diddy is right about TW, being at nearly 8 GB. Pretty significant on a 16 GB total memory.

From a Sprint Moto X using AC Forums app
 

blackdogAC

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2012
442
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

Thank you O Great Ambassadors! ;)
Right now I see that both options have advantages, and opinions are that Sense6 is significantly less intrusive than TW. There may be some very good stuff in Sense6 that I'd be giving up.
Still, if I go standard Sense on an ATT phone, I'm going to get their bloatware too. And long waits on updates.
BUT- if I go GPE, I'll have to pay $100 more...$700 plus tax straight cash!
 

uumeshh

Active member
Sep 17, 2012
32
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

the GPE would have its bootloader unlocked. this means easier rom flashing and Dev support. consider that if you like putting new roms on the phone
 

blackdogAC

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2012
442
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

I've read about flashing ROMs for years. I don't know if I'd have the guts to mess with a $700 device...plus if stock android is so great, I probably wouldn't want to move to CM or something else.

What's the legal status now regarding unlocking? If you're on ATT, can you legally obtain unlocking services on an ATT/contract phone?
 

Wildo6882

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2010
3,360
28
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

I've recently switched to AT&T and now that I can buy stock Android phones, I don't see me going to anything else. The bloated skins don't do much for me, and have tons of features that I just don't use. But like others have said, some of those features may be important to you. A lot of the extra things that skins provide can be somewhat replicated through 3rd party apps. Additionally, HTC is rumored to be releasing BlinkFeed to the masses, so you would be able to put that on stock Android, if you so desired. I also love not having to worry about carriers for updates. It's nice to have that "iOS-like" freedom where it comes straight from Google. And stock Android, IMHO, has become very beautiful in its own right, and I don't like to cover that up with flashy skins that don't do much for me.
 

blackdogAC

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2012
442
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

One more question: Are the unlocked phones (for AT&T) sold on Amazon, loaded with the carrier stuff?
 

Wildo6882

Well-known member
Aug 13, 2010
3,360
28
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

One more question: Are the unlocked phones (for AT&T) sold on Amazon, loaded with the carrier stuff?

Unlocked phones do not have the carrier bloat. They will have all of the HTC additions, however, and run Sense instead of stock Android. But they get updates from HTC instead of AT&T. If you want Sense and not stock, in my opinion, this is the way to go if you can stomach the full price of the device.
 

clevin

Well-known member
Nov 12, 2010
1,769
2
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

Stock google device has all the google apps, and provides google with unfeathered access to your personal info. If you remotely worry about privacy, it would not be a good option.

However, if you really don't care about that sort of things, Google device has frequent upgrade and give you a feeling of on the "cutting edge", who knows what that means.

PS. don't mistake stock android with stock google, there is really no stock android, a.k.a. AOSP, phone in the mass market, its all stock google. Basically, its google's bloatware vs everybody else' bloatware. There is little difference in reality.
 

Aquila

Retired Moderator
Feb 24, 2012
15,904
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

Stock google device has all the google apps, and provides google with unfeathered access to your personal info. If you remotely worry about privacy, it would not be a good option.

However, if you really don't care about that sort of things, Google device has frequent upgrade and give you a feeling of on the "cutting edge", who knows what that means.

PS. don't mistake stock android with stock google, there is really no stock android, a.k.a. AOSP, phone in the mass market, its all stock google. Basically, its google's bloatware vs everybody else' bloatware. There is little difference in reality.

What in your estimation is the distinction between the privacy and security controls on GApps on a GPe or Nexus device versus any other device with GApps installed on it (so not a Kindle Fire, I guess...) and how is that change in privacy and security controls effected?
 

Golfdriver97

Trusted Member Team Leader
Moderator
Dec 4, 2012
35,380
127
63
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

PS. don't mistake stock android with stock google, there is really no stock android, a.k.a. AOSP, phone in the mass market, its all stock google. Basically, its google's bloatware vs everybody else' bloatware. There is little difference in reality.

Actually AOSP is Android and is open source. You can flash any custom ROM without Gapps if you really want. Hard to do anything without them though.
 

adriandb

Well-known member
Mar 18, 2013
1,243
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

What in your estimation is the distinction between the privacy and security controls on GApps on a GPe or Nexus device versus any other device with GApps installed on it (so not a Kindle Fire, I guess...) and how is that change in privacy and security controls effected?
I don't want to speak for the OP, but wouldn't that suggest that he/she doesn't want Google having access to his/her calendar, email, web searches, etc?
 

Aquila

Retired Moderator
Feb 24, 2012
15,904
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

I don't want to speak for the OP, but wouldn't that suggest that he/she doesn't want Google having access to his/her calendar, email, web searches, etc?

That's what I took away from it too; I'm just wondering how it differs from any other device that has Google's apps on it. In either case the choice is the user's as to whether or not they use any of those apps and/or download other apps. What is the difference between TouchWiz, Sense, Optimus and Stock in how they handle any personal information that you do or do not submit?
 

adriandb

Well-known member
Mar 18, 2013
1,243
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

That's what I took away from it too; I'm just wondering how it differs from any other device that has Google's apps on it. In either case the choice is the user's as to whether or not they use any of those apps and/or download other apps. What is the difference between TouchWiz, Sense, Optimus and Stock in how they handle any personal information that you do or do not submit?
AOSP doesn't have google services, thus google isn't looking over your shoulder.
 

Aquila

Retired Moderator
Feb 24, 2012
15,904
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

AOSP doesn't have google services, thus google isn't looking over your shoulder.

Ah yes, let me rephrase that to the most "stock"-ish devices available for consumer purchases (Nexus and GPe devices) vs every other purchasable device (99% of which have Google services). What makes a Galaxy Note 3 more safe or more private than a Nexus?
 

blackdogAC

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2012
442
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

I'm headed towards straight-up purchase of an unlocked AT&T straight from HTC.
Anyone think this has advantages over Amazon?
Deal with Sense for a while and if the microSD issue doesn't make me nuts, hold off on root for a while.
 

ramandeepghuman

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2013
118
0
0
Visit site
Re: Can you explain the benefits of stock android?

I'm headed towards straight-up purchase of an unlocked AT&T straight from HTC.
Anyone think this has advantages over Amazon?
Deal with Sense for a while and if the microSD issue doesn't make me nuts, hold off on root for a while.

Well they just got s-off on the one m8 so ethier way you can get Google play edition on there with a customized ruu. So get the one directly from HTC is my recommendation but just don't update til you know for sure what you wanna do!

Posted via Android Central App
 

Ironzey

Well-known member
May 27, 2011
56
0
0
Visit site
Why hasn't anyone mentioned the fact that GPE doesn't have Blinkfeed, I don't think there is native support for the IR blaster, tap to turn on also GPE doesn't have support for the dot view case. Does GPE do Zoes?

These are the missing features that you will be passing up by going GPE.

Personally, the tap to wake is a big one for me. Tall display with the power button on top of the device it would be nice to have an alternative to reaching to the top of the device to wake the screen. Also the IR blaster and their TV app is something I've been wanting to try out.

I'm on the fence but leaning towards the T-mobile version.
 

Trending Posts

Forum statistics

Threads
944,428
Messages
6,922,794
Members
3,159,555
Latest member
Burks