i'm getting a replacement device tomorrow as well, not that i care if it's refurbished so long as it works right and doesn't have any signs of being used or damaged.
every refurb i've encountered with verizon had a sticker by where the esn sticker is located that stated that it was refurbished. just look for it.
but i agree that it's odd that your phone looked used. everything i've gotten was in brand new condition with all the screen protectors and everything there. the only stuff missing was the battery and any bundled memory cards that usually come with new devices.
Yeah same here, I know on all my Storm replacements the sticker was a little round green one by the esn, and a green or orange sticker on the box.