I have asked Best Buy and Verizon in detail on the insurance because last year when I did alternative upgrade due to phone breaking at basketball game Verizon "accidently" took off my insurance and I was sol. Wasn't huge deal because I got the Incredible short time later.
Ok so here is exactly what I was told and I have had both insurances.
Best Buy:
1. Price is based on retail value of phone so $10.99 per month it has to be put on to a card and it comes out for exactly 24 months.
2. No deductible but insurance does NOT cover software issues that is Verizon / Manufactor issue.
3. Lost / Stolen is NOT covered you need to bring in part of the device to get replacement. So if you run it over you have to at least bring in a piece to start the "Junk out" process in which they give you in a Best Buy gift card the orginal retail value of your phone and let you pick same phone or somethig of equal value (I just did this yesterday)
4. There is technically no limit to how many devices they will replace due to accidental damage, but they will always try to repair it before replace it. Replace devices are BRAND NEW devices.
5. If phone is fixable you will be required to put on a temp phone of your own or pay security deposit of $150.00 and wait up to 4 weeks to get your phone repaired by geek squad repair.
6. If you sell your phone or give it to a friend the warranty can be transfered to them.
7. No Lemon policy if your phone is sent in for repair for same issue you will be offered replacement device of comparable performance and value.
8. Can cancel the plan at anytime if you cancel if you cancel within 30 days of purchase you will receive full refund.
(Sidenote) As of right now Best Buy offers if you buy the Black Tie Protection Insurance you get half off new Buy Back program which is simply this. The plan is $60.00 for 24 months of its duration. Starting for first 6 months window your phone is worth 50% buy back pricing, and each six months after it goes down 10 percent. Buy back is placed in Best Buy gift card and for someone who upgrades phones more often then every two years is a nice bonus.
Verizon:
1. I was told last night the price point for insurance was not set to be equal to iphone as of yet so it will most likely be a NEW tier of insurance for 4G phones so until launch we really don't know. It could be flagged as just a "advanced device" there could be a new "4G" tier or it could be with the iphone as other device.
Does Verizon Wireless offer Total Equipment Coverage against lost/stolen/damaged and defective equipment?
Yes, Total Equipment Coverage combines the benefits of Asurion’s Wireless Phone Protection with the Verizon Wireless Extended Warranty program. If your device or covered accessories are lost, stolen, accidentally damaged, or malfunctioning due to a manufacturing defect after the manufacturer’s warranty expires, you are covered. Verizon Wireless customers can only enroll in Total Equipment Coverage within 30 days of new account activation with a new equipment purchase.
Phones
* $6.99 per month per covered phone.
* $45 non-refundable deductible per approved claim.
* 2 replacements in a 12-month period with an equipment maximum of $400 per claim (in New York, 2 claims per policy year).
Advanced Devices
* $6.99 per month per covered device.
* $99 non-refundable deductible per approved claim.
* 2 replacements in a 12-month period with an equipment maximum of $1500 per claim (in New York, 2 claims per policy year).
Tablets and Other Devices
* $10.99 per month per covered device.
* $129 non-refundable deductible (Tablets) per approved claim.
* $169 non-refundable deductible (16GB iPhone? 4) per approved claim.
* $199 non-refundable deductible (32GB iPhone 4) per approved claim.
* 2 replacements in a 12-month period with an equipment maximum of $1500 per claim (in New York, 2 claims per policy year).
* Not available for Apple? iPad™.
2. Insurance is PER device it is not per phone number or account so whoever in this thread to have been claiming to carry it over. That is only option if something went wrong with your device and they activated it on your new device. As you can read in the fine print you have 30 days to enroll you don't not have to do it the day of purchase, but to be eligible for insurance it has 30 day window upon NEW device activation.
Trust me when I emphasis the last part in folks who claim it carrys over for them. I had insurance on my MAIN line and used that upgrade to my 3rd line due to broken device at basketball game. Little over a month later I had dropped my phone off top my car and called in to start process to get new phone (right before Incredible came out) I was informed sir you have NO insurance on your main line. When you "Activated" your new device you didn't get insurance on that new device so your 3rd line has none and you lost insurance on your main line.
3. As listed above unlike Best Buy there is deductable and it is pretty hefty and your replacement device is a like new warranty replacement not a new phone or credit towards a new phone.
All in all after insurance debacle I went with Best Buy for right now $9.99 price tag and as you can see everyone will have different experiences. Yet they sent my phone in a week ago for repair and when it didn't fix it I got $600.00 gift card for new device of my choice day it came back. So in my experience I would always like the security of having a NEW device.
Want to state I do not work for either place of business and again have had both types of insurances. Some people might of have "special" senarios where they were covered differently, but from all my experiences and wording you have to accept the insurance is is never put on there from previous phone for either service. This information is directly from Verizon website to best of my knowledge most recent policies and directly from Best Buys "Geek Squad Black Tie Protection" booklet.