Just got my case...quick shipping!
I dislike how loosely the case grips the phone, but other than that I'm happy with the purchase. There are no cut-outs for the side and top buttons, but that doesn't hinder pressing them, and there are even little rubber impressions where the buttons are so you can find them if you look closely.
If the case gripped the phone more tightly, and if it had cutouts for the buttons, I'd give it 5 stars. But I don't regret buying it. It looks nearly identical to the HTC case of the same price, available at the AC store.