I would say it definitely depends on how you would use the smartwatch. I have the Gear 2 paired with the Note 3 and couldn't be happier. My main use is to get notifications/ calls when I am away from my desk (and my phone) at work. As long as I am within 50 feet or so of my phone I never miss a message or call. If you prefer to leave the phone and still use the watch alone, then you would be better served by the Gear S. Of course, Samsung always seems to sweeten each new model, so if you can wait a while longer go for the new model when it arrives.