I got a 128GB Pixel in March, coming from a Moto X Pure Edition. Before that, I had a Droid Maxx (which I have reactivated on a secondary line). The Pixel is taller than the Maxx, but the screen size is about the same.
I liked the MXPE, but after going back to this size, I am very happy with the Pixel. I just couldn't justify the price difference for that 0.5".
The battery life on the Pixel is much better than the MXPE. I can get a full day of moderate use out of the Pixel. I needed a charger always at hand for the MXPE