Another alternative, albeit not the best solution, is to buy the black silicone case from Verizon. Not the shiny "hard" silicone cases but the standard black silicone ones. For some reason they designed those silicone cases to go over the buttons and cover them, maybe for better protection? But in any case, I can confirm that they hide the buttons well and no light comes through the silicone at all. Also gives it a better feel in hand while holding the phone reading something on it.