If you read my post, I said exactly what I was doing (sans the part about trying to keep it away from someone's grabby little rugrat that wanted to play with it). I've been carrying a PDA or smartphone since the PalmPilot, and laptops daily since the mid-90's, and have never had to replace one due to damage. I'm careful with my things, but I use them. My phone is a tool that sees use. Ask any photographers whether they leave thier best cameras or lenses safe at home because it might get scratched, and they'll tell you that that they'll never get that once-in-a-lifetime shot with a camera that's at home or safely in it's case. My S3 is not my most precious possession that sits behind glass in some display case, and nwo that it's damaged, I'll deal with it, but get off your high horse, because one day something will happen to yours, too.
@ Skunkape - $120 doesn't sound too bad... Maybe I'll swing by the Sprint store tonight and ask them. I didn't think they would do repairs (only swaps for phones under the protection plan). Thanks.