Castor Troy
Banned
Ok, I'm usually with you CK, but I have to disagree here. The Bionic and GSII are very similar devices. If you go down the list, the features are almost identical. Implementations are different such as pentile vs. SAMOLED+. But, things like form factor, screen size, memory capacity, CPU, etc., are nearly the same. Now, you and I put more weight into specific implementation details that the average consumer doesn't, and that helps us separate the two. But, to the average consumer, they're almost identical, with the screen being the biggest discriminator. This would especially be true if they are both 4G/LTE.
That said, the Bionic may be "marketed" towards a slightly different consumer with the webtop capabilities. But, that was such a failure that I don't really see that as a big discriminator and enough to edge it into being an "entirely different device".
Yes correct the implementation of the hardware is nearly identical so that is a wash. Keep in mind your average consumer can't be sold a tegra, ti omap or Exynos. They also can't be sold a super amoled or pentile for that matter. If it looks good to them they will buy it. So what makes the Bionic standout if it really is just another Android phone. WebTop and accessories. Those will be key selling points. The commercials (if there are any) will reflect the capabilities and the set ups at the stores will showcase the capabilities as well.
Its about capabilities and the GS2 or any other phone in verizons line up does not have these capabilities. Atrix was marketed as the most powerful smartphone on the market and why? Because of its capabilities. its like no other Android phone. Take away those capabilities and what do you have? Just another smart phone.
I agree with you when you say it (webtop) was a failure. 100% agree. I said above that its a waste and will kill sales regardless what new phone comes out at that time. Most people don't need that nonsense and will move onto another device in their line up be it the GS2 (if its released ) Charge, TB, DX2 etc etc. TB is just as new and exciting to your average consumer.
I had one guy tell me he was upgrading to the Thunderbolt because it was a "really cool phone." He had no concept of it being "old" or "outdated" let alone only a Single Core handset. We laugh but that's the way people are.
Sent from my Droid