I had the Incipio dual layer for months, it was nice but I felt that a good drop would kill the phone. Had the Defender on the phone for 8-9 days. It's rugged and the the rubber outer layer is better than precious models. BUT I do NOT like 1) the holster - it's noisy, flimsy, and loose; 2) the hard inner case really interferes when typing and hitting the menu and back buttons.
I wish I had gotten the Sedio Active, though it's not perfect either.
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Android Central Forums
I use the white and gray commuter otterbox case. It's durable and the case is surprisingly resistant to dirt and/or marks. I actually got a large amount of black sharpie ink on the back a few days ago and, fortunately, it all came right off. The same goes for any other stray marks that have appeared. It's protective without being too bulky and has a nice grip. The white looks good on the white s3.
Sent from my Galaxy S III