Ok so far I'm liking the Kraken 2. I've somehow managed to drop my phone at least 5 times from about 4-5 feet and the case has held up fantastic. It is a little on the big side, but I have big hands and actually welcomed the thought of being able to hold the phone and it feeling comfortable. The downside is being able to drag the top of the screen down, but I quickly found out for me it's about how fast I try to pull down the bar and have remedied that. I have the most problems with letters on the side if I try to text in portrait, but have no problems in landscape.
The glaring downside is the holster. The pro is that it fits snug, but the downside is the rubber and plastic fight each other. Maybe it's because it's still new for me and only time will tell if that gets easier to take the phone in and out. The biggest downside about the holster I noticed is the clip. It's all plastic. I was thinking there might be a springed hinge, but sadly there isn't one. I would say at it's widest opening, you have less than 1/4th of an inch to get it on your belt and take it off. Kind of a pain.
Overall I would rate the actual case though a 8.5/10 and would give the holster a 3/10.