My JUMP was up in July, so I had my pick of the litter. Now... the M8. First, coming from a Nexus 5, the M8's software
felt the best of any non-Nexus phone. It was laid out similar to my Nexus 5 and it was the only one that came close (but not matching) the fluidity. An unmodified Nexus 5 is a sight to behold in terms of smoothness. But in any case... the G3 doesn't match that overall fluidity, but that's only noticeable if I held them side by side.... which I shopped doing due to the fact that my Nexus is getting shipped off to T-Mobile this week and using it only gives me buyers remorse.
That was such an awesome phone.... but I'm moving on and the G3 was my choice.
I have two issues with the M8.... Unless you are taking selfies and only posting on instagram, the camera has problems. Yes, pixel counts aren't the end-all when comparing cameras, but when you put a 4MP shooter up against cams that pack 2 (Nexus 5, iPhone 5s) or 3 times (S5, G3) the detail, that deficiency is going to become a problem if you want to use the phone as your daily, out and about camera. Secondly, I don't listen to music much on my phone (and when I do, I use headphones. So speakers aren't high on my list. Yeah, they sound incredible, especially when compared to other phones. But they also take up a LOT of space. The HTC is actually TALLER than the G3 and side by side, and the M8 looked oddly dis-proportioned with a ton of room lost to bezel/speaker. The M8 is a great phone, just not a great phone for me.... If I didn't need a workable camera and speaker sound was important, that would probably be THE phone.
The S5? Well... I don't like the S5 because, well, because Samsung. Great hardware.... rest blows. From the not just locked, but
encrypted bootloaders to the heavily laded-down Touchwiz interface. Samsung, you suck. Enough already.
But I have some detailed opinions over on a thread I started :
Former Nexus 5 zealot's first impressions. I'm not yet on a week with the phone, so that thread is stream of consciousness.