Is the Pixel 2 too small?

[dmateo]

Been using it for a few days now, and although I bought it with the purpose of having a smaller device, coming from a Note 8 it's taking a bit of time to adjust. I'm loving the portability of the phone and how nice it is to reach the top of the device without having to move it down while holding it.

I really wanted something smaller so I guess that's what I got. I'm really enjoying the stock Android experience. I tried the pixel 2xl and wasn't really a fan of how it felt in my hands. I have pretty big hands as I'm 6'4 but just didn't like the feel. I hope the pixel 3 comes in at the same size with a larger screen, I think it's really more the 5 inch screen vs. the 6 of the note 8 that takes more getting used to than anything.

All in all I'm very happy with the purchase!

I missed having a phone this small!

 

[cbreze]

My phone history has 3 phab sized phones in it and I for one am doubtful I'd ever get another large phone. Smaller/larger being better is just a matter of opinion. I hear Apple is coming out with a 6.5" phone later this year. Yikes, that's really huge.
I recall many, many moons ago when larger phones were kind of disliked and rare as a general rule. I had a 3" screen on my windows pro device and my friends all thought it was way to huge. Ha,ha. Now look at what is available. I like the size of my P2 and if it had half the bezel size it would be even sweeter and smaller. i have an iPhone7 I used for 6 months before getting the pixel and delegating the iPhone to the back burner of backup devices. But one of the best features of that phone IMHO is the small size(4.7"). So easy to carry and a powerhouse in a small package. I hope the pixel line continues to offer a smaller device along with the XL.

 

[KrisYYC]

My phone history has 3 phab sized phones in it and I for one am doubtful I'd ever get another large phone. Smaller/larger being better is just a matter of opinion. I hear Apple is coming out with a 6.5" phone later this year. Yikes, that's really huge.
I recall many, many moons ago when larger phones were kind of disliked and rare as a general rule. I had a 3" screen on my windows pro device and my friends all thought it was way to huge. Ha,ha. Now look at what is available. I like the size of my P2 and if it had half the bezel size it would be even sweeter and smaller. i have an iPhone7 I used for 6 months before getting the pixel and delegating the iPhone to the back burner of backup devices. But one of the best features of that phone IMHO is the small size(4.7"). So easy to carry and a powerhouse in a small package. I hope the pixel line continues to offer a smaller device along with the XL.

Agreed. What's great about the Pixel line is that Google doesn't neuter the smaller one somehow like Apple and Samsung do by putting a weaker camera on the regular iPhone and Galaxy S8/S9.

I have a Note 8 as well as Pixel 2 but the Note 8 is a bit cumbersome as a daily driver. The screen sure is nice though.

 

[anon(10092459)]

I could actually stand it a hair smaller, tbh.. I've never liked big phones for pocketability reasons mainly. I generally keep a tablet in my tech lineup if I need a bigger screen.

 

[Armeniandave]

I have the Pixel 2 XL and just had the Pixel 2 and an Essential phone. In terms of size the Essential was perfect. 5.7" phone in a compact size was awesome. Unfortunately the signal strength made me sell it. The regular Pixel 2 was just too small a screen for the size of the phone. It was almost the same size as the Essential but much smaller screen. The regular Pixel 2 XL is a little bigger but it seems to be a better option for me as it has a large screen and it's not too big relatively.

 

[dmateo]

I have the Pixel 2 XL and just had the Pixel 2 and an Essential phone. In terms of size the Essential was perfect. 5.7" phone in a compact size was awesome. Unfortunately the signal strength made me sell it. The regular Pixel 2 was just too small a screen for the size of the phone. It was almost the same size as the Essential but much smaller screen. The regular Pixel 2 XL is a little bigger but it seems to be a better option for me as it has a large screen and it's not too big relatively.

I agree, the essential was absolutely perfect had it not been for the poor signal in NYC

 

[ImTurningViolet]

I love it. I would have gotten a cheaper Moto phone if they were pixel 2 size. The smaller size and camera were the two main reasons I went with a pixel.

 

[snowboarders]

i find the pixel 2 to be the right sizes for me not too big not too tall not too wide like samsung phones are

 

[Nubwy]

I prefer the Pixel 2 in the smaller size personally. Sold my Note 8 and have been using this ever since. The battery life took a hit, but I've reduced my useage and I'm chugging along just fine. There was an article recently about how battery life on most phones is good; we just need to get off our phones more.

 

[dmateo]

I prefer the Pixel 2 in the smaller size personally. Sold my Note 8 and have been using this ever since. The battery life took a hit, but I've reduced my useage and I'm chugging along just fine. There was an article recently about how battery life on most phones is good; we just need to get off our phones more.

I agree... Most of us who ***** about battery life are on our phones excessively.

 

[psteve2005]

I think the overall footprint is perfect.

I seem to swap between small and large phones on an annual basis but always prefer the smaller size. Any phone that I have to take out of my pocket to do up my shoes fails my test!

Whenever I'm tempted to go back to a bigger phone I ask myself why, as bigger isn't always better. If I want to play a game I use my PS4 not my phone, and to watch a film or YouTube I cast it to the TV, so for me the only benefit of a big phone is the bigger battery.

I think my ideal Pixel 3 would be the same size as the P2/S9/iPhone X, with a 5.8" screen and wireless charging. Now that would be perfect...for me.

 

[dmateo]

I think the overall footprint is perfect.

I seem to swap between small and large phones on an annual basis but always prefer the smaller size. Any phone that I have to take out of my pocket to do up my shoes fails my test!

Whenever I'm tempted to go back to a bigger phone I ask myself why, as bigger isn't always better. If I want to play a game I use my PS4 not my phone, and to watch a film or YouTube I cast it to the TV, so for me the only benefit of a big phone is the bigger battery.

I think my ideal Pixel 3 would be the same size as the P2/S9/iPhone X, with a 5.8" screen and wireless charging. Now that would be perfect...for me.

You just described the S9 in your last paragraph lol

 

[Nubwy]

Well, if the next Pixel had a curved screen on both models I would stick with my Pixel 2. Many folks dislike the curved glass.

 

[toiday]

The size of the Pixel 2 is perfect for me. I do wish the screen can stretch further to the edges like the XL. Now that Google have their own phone design engineers, the future gens will only get better. One thing I hope they will keep is the front speakers. There is no need to fill up the entire phone with screen. I played with the S9 a little and my hand keep accidentally touch something at the edges. It looks nice that way but not practical to use.

 

[psteve2005]

You just described the S9 in your last paragraph lol

Indeed. If it was consistently as secure as my stock Android phone I'd probably buy one.

 

[bhatech]

Size is perfect but I need more battery life and hence go for the bigger models like 2 XL over 2, S9+ over S9 etc.
If you are light user the smaller phone should carry thru the day just fine but I like to have that piece of mind and have the max battery possible at the expense of ergonomics.

 

[Ca_lvn]

It's not too small the bezels are too big

 

[mmcclure0453]

I like the size of the Pixel 2. But, I also have an S8 and I prefer the screen on it. How about hardware of S8/S9 with stock Android.

I'm leaning toward the S9 with bigger screen, wireless charging, and stereo speakers... The camera has proven to be a Pixel 2 contender also.

But, giving up the smoothness of the Pixel 2 would be hard. The Galaxy phones have gotten much better but they still stutter here and there.

 

[Theot]

Well, if the next Pixel had a curved screen on both models I would stick with my Pixel 2. Many folks dislike the curved glass.

Count me in. I bought a G6 last year because I don't like curved screens. I played with the S9 & S9+ a couple times in store. It doesn't seem useful to me, it's just a gimmick. That said I think I'm ready for a better camera and software experience so the G6 is about to get sold for a pixel 2.

The size of the Pixel 2 is perfect for me. I do wish the screen can stretch further to the edges like the XL. Now that Google have their own phone design engineers, the future gens will only get better. One thing I hope they will keep is the front speakers. There is no need to fill up the entire phone with screen. I played with the S9 a little and my hand keep accidentally touch something at the edges. It looks nice that way but not practical to use.

Yep, I did the same with the S9, kept turning something on with the edge screen just trying to hold onto the phone. No thanks.

It looks like the pixel 2 is just a tad smaller than my G6 and I love the size of the G6, the screen is fantastic but the camera and software quarks leave me wanting so I think I'm ready to go for the pixel 2. When I first looked at the pixel 2 I didn't think I could give up my screen but I've come around on that idea just to get the software and camera.

 

[sulla1965]

Yes its just a bit too small. it feels smaller than other 5.0 inch devices. I feel 5.5 is the smallest a screen should be.