Wow! Reading the posts in this forum reminds me of exactly what's wrong in America today. Regular people don't stand up for what they believe in anymore, and when someone does they quickly quell that notion with sit down and shut up for complaining.
Regardless of whether the OP roots or not, he still had a valid complaint. He could have actually rooted or updated his phone, and he would still have a valid complaint. A really valid complaint. You realize that by paying him that Verizon admitted guilt and set a precedent? It is in hope that he will just go away and be quiet about it. He could really make some headway into this if he wanted to...
I understand that the dev community does many great things for us Android users, and I more than applaud that, but that doesn't mean that we shouldn't still hold manufacturers and carriers to task for promises made on their products and services. In fact, it can be argued now, that manufacturers are delegating their responsibility to devs without compensating them.
We should not castigate someone for doing the right thing even if there is another way for them to remedy the problem and move on regardless of whether they have other options or not. We should also not take a defeatist attitude towards change in corporate America spamming thoughts of "it will never happen." When did we become so complacent?
If police are corrupt and do not do their jobs, you don't tell people to stop complaining, that's the way it is, the vigilante community will take care of it. It's amazing what corporations get away with in the world of Mobile that no other industry can get away with.