Any solutions or other similar cases to buy and return this one?

[Android Central Question]

I bought a case for my Moto G6 Play, the Poetic Revolution since I had to get a new phone(I dropped my other one) and now the screen protector won't let me phone fit into it and into the case itself. The Case would physically not let the phone into the screen protector. No matter how much you pushed, one side will always pop out if you push the other in.