If the Inc 2 was more of an upgrade than it is I would probably jump on that one but personally I am going to enjoy making Verizon squirm a little.
But I love mine and there are so many Roms out there I can change it every other day.
I loved my incredible, but I have to say, though mine can't be rooted yet, my inc 2 was worth the upgrade. 3g got faster with the upgrade to gingerbread, and the 4 inch screen is perfect. Sharper than my OG Inc, and I have no complaints with the SLCD screen. Plus battery life is MUCH better. But if customization is what you want the most, then stick with the first incredible. Mine will get there, but it will take some time.
Sent from my DInc 2