Do you need a task manager installed?

dagostin

Well-known member
Nov 9, 2009
294
1
0
Visit site
I do not think using or not using a task killer has to become a religion that some just believe in and others do not. The warnings have been stated about potential issues with task killers (i.e. killing programs that need to stay running). Please be aware that there are many ways to use a task killer. For example, you can install a task killer that does not automatically kill anything. I used Advanded task Manager for example, and it has a setting about whether or not you want to kill running apps after X minutes based on priorities, etc. With this off, the task killer doesn't do anything on its own. There is also a setting for automatically run on start. Without that, it doesn't run on its own.

Now, this is how i set it up. If i feel like seeing available RAM or seeing whats running, I launch the task killer app. If desired i can kill stuff, if not i dont. How do I then kill the task manager app if desired? Easily, you use the task killer to kill itself and thats all. If not, android OS steps in after a while and kills it as that's how the OS works in general. All that said, with my settings of not having the task killer auto kill anything, i do not need to kill it manually "to save battery." I've been running it since day 1 and task killer has NEVER shown on up on my batter usage stats. Yes it uses some but the use is negligible in the mode i use it.

I think of a task killer program as an equivalent to windows Task Manager, with some extra features that I don't use. It's just an efficient way for me to view tasks/processes/services if i desire. I know i can find this info already but its easier with the task manager. In the event that an app does have a bug and is hogging battery or running incessantly that the OS doesn't prevent, only then do i use a task killer to destory the app.

Bottom line is that task killers do not have to function as an always running app that manages the app space in addition to the android OS doing this. Simply put, is a task manager needed? No. Do they cause more harm than good? Maybe, but depends on how you use it. Is it easier to power off then use a task manager for the rare times when you actually need to kill stuff? Definitely not.
 

colecolecole

Active member
Nov 21, 2009
39
1
0
Visit site
Memory?

when i go into advanced task killer , my available memory after closing everything is 59m

is this normal? what is everyone else running ? and does this directly effect phone speed ?
 

dagostin

Well-known member
Nov 9, 2009
294
1
0
Visit site
yes that more than normal. I've only seen some lag when its dipped below 30MB and thats only ever happened to me on a rooted/modified rom that had other issues.
 

prometheus

Well-known member
Jan 5, 2010
675
8
0
Visit site
So, the end result is that when used very sparingly, and only when called for, task killers are helpful. But, they're useless out harmful if not used with skill. OK, I suppose that rationale applies to most apps.

By the way, on the subject of monitoring CPU usage and all of that geek stuff.... I just stumbled upon a free app in Market called OSMonitor. it provides a plethora of information on running apps and may be helpful to someone who wants to totally geek out.
 

Adrynalyne

Account Deactivated
Dec 24, 2009
1,346
1,534
0
Visit site
So, the end result is that when used very sparingly, and only when called for, task killers are helpful. But, they're useless out harmful if not used with skill. OK, I suppose that rationale applies to most apps.

By the way, on the subject of monitoring CPU usage and all of that geek stuff.... I just stumbled upon a free app in Market called OSMonitor. it provides a plethora of information on running apps and may be helpful to someone who wants to totally geek out.



Very nice summary. I agree that using it blindly without knowing really whats going on is probably going to hurt more than help.
 
Last edited:

471405

Well-known member
Dec 20, 2009
64
2
0
Visit site
I read this entire thread through out today... very interesting. I'm not going to uninstall ATK, but I will start using it sparingly (probably to close youtube app, which has been in my ATK list for the past 4 hours).

Coming from the Pre, I have no complaints about the Droid's battery.
 
Aug 1, 2010
18
0
0
Visit site
Does anyone know how to KILL an app?

I use Advanced Task Manager. It kills apps for a few moments and then they open again. Is there no way to actually stop programs and services from running?

I HATE apps that do not die when you end them, or even worse apps that I didn't even ask to open automatically open on their own.

Paypal, Yahoo Mail, Ebay, and many more apps just run background services that can't or won't be closed. Uninstalled. I just don't know enough about Android's app management life cycles to understand why apps don't die.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
950,329
Messages
6,946,807
Members
3,161,916
Latest member
sgmahca