Re: How dod I turn off the S5's camera's shutter 'click'?
Its a law in most states that u cannot turn it off
Is that a joke?
I think
kregstrong means sovereign nation-states, not constituent States of the USA or any other country that is divided into states.
No, it's no joke. In some cultures it may be taken as serious affront to take a picture of anybody, or their property, without their knowledge or permission. In the Western world the German-speaking countries are noted for this, which is why you will find almost no Google Street View coverage there and probably never will.
From the website of Austrian radio station OE24:
Lenker mit Kamera-Ausrüstung müssen mit hohen Strafen rechnen.
Die präventive Videoüberwachung aus dem Auto heraus durch Privatpersonen ist nicht zulässig. Darauf machte am Montag die ARGE Daten aufmerksam, nachdem die Datenschutzkommission einem entsprechenden Vorhaben eines Antragstellers eine Abfuhr erteilt hat. Nach dieser Entscheidung, so die ARGE, muss jeder Autofahrer mit einer Videoausstattung mit einer Anzeige und einer Verwaltungsstrafe in der Höhe von bis zu 10.000 Euro, im Wiederholungsfall bis zu 25.000 Euro rechnen.
Unerwünscht gefilmte Personen könnten noch dazu zivilrechtlichen Schadenersatz bis zu 20.000 Euro beanspruchen.
Translation:
Motorists with camera set-ups should expect heavy fines
The preventive video surveillance from an auto by private citizens is not permitted. ARGE Daten (Austrian non-profit advocacy group for data privacy) drew attention to this, after the Austrian Data Protection Authority denied the application of one motorist [
to be granted official license for such a camera]. Following this decision, motorists using such equipment may be fined 10000 Euros, or 25000 on repeated violations.
Aditionally, individuals filmed against their wishes can sue for up to 20,000 Euros in civil damages.
The second article I linked to, in the English translation, also explains that the person who applied for the permission was doing so in the interest of legal due diligence. It's unclear to me that anyone had ever officially suggested that a licensing system for this should have been set up.
The underlying legal principle is essentially that the right of non-involved third parties not to have themselves or their belongings photographed trumps the supposedly legitimate utility of camera footage in the investigation of accidents, because the pursuit and punishment of traffic violators remains the job of law enforcement, not private citizens.
So...you wanted to snap a few pictures on your phone without bystanders being aware? And without even the sensible precaution of wishing to protect yourself in case you're accused of causing an accident by tailgating the car in front of you? Ha! While Austria's laws don't apply elsewhere, some other countries do have shutter silencing bans, so phones that disable or omit the silencing feature are increasingly the norm.
However, I found that
Chris' fix in
post #10 worked fine. I was surprised because in the past I've always had to root my phone and make a small adjustment to a couple of system files. I just got the S5 last week, and I'm rooted now, but I couldn't find the files I usually rename or edit.