The difference between a full list and a clear one is ... about nothing, unless the app you want to run is showing on the screen. Clearing the list doesn't close the apps or remove them from RAM, it just removes them from the list. Then there's nothing there, so if you want to run an app you ran recently, it's not there. If it's 15 apps up, it's also not convenient. But the last 4 or 5 apps are ready for you to run with a tap.
The "close all" button was really worthless. First, it didn't "close" anything, and second why would you care if there are apps showing in the list - it has no effect on how the phone is operating.