No, I had the Active case as seen below. Later I had the one that was the surface case inside an active case but the surface case would just ruin my screen protector. No way to get the phone into the case without it catching on the protector.
The Otterbox case I have is similar in design and has its own problems. It had a flap covering up the ports on the bottom that I ended up cutting off after a couple of days. The silicone part doesn't fit the phone as well as the Seidio case but the plastic shell has not fallen apart.
OK, missed that. I only had their surface case. Now you have me wondering why too. ;-)