I think this is actually a very interesting thread because people are trying to get to the root of why people might prefer iOS or Android without getting defensive or getting personal. This is my first Android experience and I can see the pros and cons of both.
I come from the Mac side (iphone, iMac, all the way back to Mac IIcx!) and the state of Android now really reminds me of the days when Mac was the underdog and everyone said it was only a matter of time before Windows would land the knock out blow (which it almost did!), The biggest difference now however, is the boatload of money that Google can throw behind Android that Apple didn't have at the time. However, there is a definite David vs. Goliath mentality going on which is actually really refreshing on the Android side.
That said, as it was when the Mac was down, it's important not to gloss over the deficiencies of Android so that they can be identified and improved upon.
So my take on after opening my Tab box and turning the 10.1 on for the first time.
- Honeycomb really is much, much close to a computer experience than the iPad. You attack the problems the same way, you try to fix it the same way, but it requires a certain level of expertise. Not as much as a full blown computer, but certainly more than an iPad. Everything is pretty easy to do in honeycomb - IF YOU KNOW HOW! Transfer files to a folder - simple - if you know how. Changing the preference of the browser from mobile to desktop - simple - if you know how. Even finding a honeycomb version of an app in the Marketplace ... well, not simple and I still don't know how!
- The thing that Apple gets right is that they have a history of customer service that Google simply does not have. They identify what might be hard for a user to understand and they attack it. They tweak UI to an inch of it's life because it helps the customer experience. This forum is the closest to customer service that Google has for Honeycomb! How crazy is that?
- However, with the iPad, Apple has gone so far to take any guesswork out of the product that they've created an appliance. In the same way that there is no guesswork with a toaster there is no guesswork with an iPad. It is what it is - take it or leave it. Since Apple has already shown their cards with iOS 5, the iPad will not have Flash, will be at least another year or two before widgets, real multi-tasking, or even a way to break out of their 5 x 4 gird of icons. The iPad is a great app appliance that can't get any better than the iPhone because it's so tied into the iPhone OS.
- Honeycomb (or Ice Cream whatever) - will make quicker strides because that's the way Google rolls. Throw something against the wall and let someone else tell you how it works. A month later throw something else up.
- I'm loving my Tab 10.1, but I also love my iPhone. But, I don't want an iPhone experience for my tablet or vice-versa. Honeycomb is frustrating, rewarding, fun and stupid all at the same time. Would I recommend an Android tablet to my Grandma or friend who is not tech savvy - no way! I would recommend it to someone who wants to be on the cutting edge and wants a tablet to be more than an App appliance though.
Just my 2 (Lo-o-o-o-ng) cents.