MKBHD Camera Comparison

[Aquila]

Okay, I'll bite here ... If you're truly taking objective measurements into account, then there's no way you can make the iPhone a distant second to the Pixel. Second, yes... but a "distant" ..?

I think I misworded that. I mean 1 and 2 were close to my preferences and third place was a long ways behind the iPhone. But that's the "my preference" part.

The second paragraph is that what I think doesn't matter at all (nor what you think or any number of people) when trying to determine which one is actually objectively the best - because that's an objective measurement of what is actually most accurate to the scene.

We don't actually have a ranking on the G6, OP3T or S8/S8+ yet - so it's kind of difficult to state where exactly they ought to place, but if we were to assume that each one is better than the prior iteration, which was Pixel > S7 Edge > G5 = iPhone 7 > OnePlus 3, then we could assume that it's still Pixel >= S8 > G6 >= iPhone 7 >= OnePlus 3T.

 

[dlalonde]

Wow! I'm really surprised. I thought the Galaxy would win for me but no OnePlus 3T! (not telling which is which though, do it yourself! )

 

[anon(10092459)]

I think I misworded that. I mean 1 and 2 were close to my preferences and third place was a long ways behind the iPhone. But that's the "my preference" part.

The second paragraph is that what I think doesn't matter at all (nor what you think or any number of people) when trying to determine which one is actually objectively the best - because that's an objective measurement of what is actually most accurate to the scene.

We don't actually have a ranking on the G6, OP3T or S8/S8+ yet - so it's kind of difficult to state where exactly they ought to place, but if we were to assume that each one is better than the prior iteration, which was Pixel > S7 Edge > G5 = iPhone 7 > OnePlus 3, then we could assume that it's still Pixel >= S8 > G6 >= iPhone 7 >= OnePlus 3T.

Okay yeah, I see what you're saying. For me, I asked what would the human eye really see and the coloring on some of pictures in this unscientific test were just way different in a lot of them.

 

[Jeremiah Bonds]

The s8 is super blue.

 

[edubb256]

B and C were my favorites by B slightly edge out C.

 

[Tarah Sorber]

Mine were C and D. Pixel and iPhone.

 

[Rumline]

The s8 is super blue.

Yeah, I can't believe how consistent the color shift is in that set. Easy to make a Lightroom rule for, unfortunately most of my phone pics never make it into Lightroom. The S8's rendering of the yellow line in the car pic is pretty bad also.

 

[Rumline]

B and C were my favorites by B slightly edge out C.

I dunno, to me, C crushes B in the first four photos. The next two are toss-ups and B wins the last one.

 

[ThrottleJohnny]

A is far too foggy and hazy. Love the clarity and vibrance of B and C.